
By: Ales Kot (story), Garry Brown (art), Jim Charalampidis (colors)
The Story: Homeland security just got the ultimate bodyguard.
The Review: I never know how to feel about minority superheroes who are basically derivatives of better known (white) icons. It’s great to see the field grow more diverse, no matter how it happens, I suppose. On the other hand, it also suggests a lack of confidence or imagination—hard to say which is worse—in creating minority characters who are completely original. The eponymous star of this book has failed that test twice.
Or maybe thrice, depending on how you look at things. As the former War Machine, James Rhodes was basically Iron Man with a different paint job and bigger guns. As Iron Patriot, he’s a clear amalgam of both Iron Man and Captain America, an attempt to channel Tony Stark’s technology with Steve Rogers’ rousing nationalism. James’ choice of guise instantly doubles the pressure for him to sell the man underneath. Without Tony’s genius or Steve’s might, what is James without the armor?
If you come into the issue with those doubts, the opening pages will do nothing to alleviate them, as we see James, unarmored, splayed on the dirt, his opponent standing by and mocking him. “I can’t save you,” James internally monologues. “I am sorry.” This is our hero?
To be sure, there are forces arrayed against James, less because of the physical threat he poses as Iron Patriot but rather because of what he stands for. If nothing else, James is a man who lives and dies by “my principles. I have to help this country. I’m protecting it.” James’ speech at his press conference is rife with star-spangled values and symbolism, bookended by a chorus of “America is my home.” You wouldn’t think any American can really critique those sentiments, but there you have it. One legislator sums up his beef against James’ speech by saying, “The perception needs to change.” Another conspirator, one with a rather fancy military medal in his possession,* emphasizes the need to “[a]djust the plan…[b]efore the media arrive.” Clearly, this is a conflict of ideas, a struggle to control the American identity, although in precisely what way remains a little vague.
Despite an express mission statement—an American focus, of course, with exceptions for rescue missions—James isn’t all that different from the hundreds of American superheroes who pretty much do the same thing. Where he really separates himself is in his tight interactions with his dad, Terrence, and niece, Lila. In most comics, the family is usually an incidental part of the superhero’s life, either a threat to his secret identity, a part of his mission objective, or occasional support. From the start, Kot establishes Terrence and Lila as integral players of Iron Patriot, and James’ relationships with them give this issue most of its emotional weight. His public service is all well and good, but the moment where you really connect with James is after a visit to his dad, when he’s home alone, murmuring, “I love you, Dad. I love you, Dad. Just say it next time. What are you afraid of?” A simple set of lines that says so much about his history with Terrence, without using so many words.
I don’t know if Kot has a certain type as far as artists go, but there’s definitely a resemblance between Brown’s work here and the work Patrick Zircher did for Kot on Suicide Squad. Both have a style which tends to emphasize shape more than line, meaning heavy inks that suggest form more often than defining it. The quality of Brown’s art is comparable to Zircher’s, though Brown’s characters tend to lose definition and consistency in smaller panels. Colors are obviously crucial to the success of Brown’s style, needing to be strong enough to stand up to the inks, but not so strong as to muddy the overall look of the page. Charalampadis strikes this balance well, and artistically, Iron Patriot is a pleasant, if not outstanding, reading experience.
Conclusion: There’s more you’d like to know, especially about the eponymous hero, before you commit yourself, but Iron Patriot’s first outing is solid in most of the areas where it counts.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * Can anyone identify that medal as a real military honor, or something made up for Marvel purposes?
– It’s a pity that Carol’s off-planet at the moment. Would like to see how Kot handles her.
– The song James is singing as he investigates the underwater foundations of New Orleans is, of course, Jimi Hendrix’s “Can You See Me?”
Grade
Conclusion