![]()
By: Neil Gaiman (story), J.H. Williams III (art), Dave Stewart (colors)
The Story: It takes only the end of one dream to start the end of the universe.
The Review: Does anyone remember the scheduling debacle that was Jonathan Hickman’s S.H.I.E.L.D., otherwise known as the First Arc That Would Never End? You can forgive parched periods between issues if each one carried enough substance to tide you over to the next, but it’s too much for someone to sustain interest for months on the typical issue. It’s now been five months since Sandman #1; Gaiman needs to make #2 worth the wait.
Certainly, this is a dense issue, full of material you have to sift through for answers, much like any dream. The opening of Daniel, the most current Dream, bears no relation to the affairs of his past self. If there’s a connection at all, you’ll have to dig for it under all of Mad Hettie’s troubled backstory and Daniel’s riddles concerning a watch she had hidden: “Time goes in so many ways… It runs. Sometimes it even flies. But as for telling the time…sometimes what time tells us is for it alone to know.”
Fortunately, Gaiman is more direct in the rest of the issue—direct for Gaiman, that is, meaning a lot of metaphor and musing* even when the characters insist on getting to the point. The discussion among the various Dreams almost resembles a Socratic exchange at certain points, as each Dream strives to make his point and take control of the conversation. “There is no us, there is only I,” says one.
“Unarguably, there is us,” another contradicts, “a multiplicity of viewpoint. More than one of me is, by definition, us.”
They get back on track eventually, realizing the manifestation of Dream’s countless aspects is a graphic way of showing that one has been “removed from existence,” and “the orderly transfer to another facet of Dream has been interrupted.” Even the why of such a phenomenon is laid bare, as the Dream of the first created things explains, “The universe has lived too long. It is time for it to end… It is in the darkness… I talk of laws… The laws on which the universe runs. The law of conservation of reality.”
His choice of words suggests the second law of thermodynamics, which describes the ever darkening and cooling of the universe via entropy, meaning its inevitable doom. Indeed, a later scene featuring a night-skinned woman bathing in darkness has her declaring, “Long, long, ago, all this was mine. In time, it will be mine again.” It’s apparent she sees her time coming. “Above her, in the universe, a star flares and goes out. She smiles. It is better than nothing.”
Yet this isn’t what Glory of the First Circle says is happening. “A star has gone mad,” he tells one Dream after another, and the madness is spreading. So perhaps an unnatural quickening of the universe’s death is taking place, one which Glory blames on Dream himself. But even on this point, there are different perspectives. Glory suggests the cause is “a child”; Dream refers to it as “a vortex,” and he let “her” live. By the end of the issue, you feel yourself drawing near to understanding, but just before you can grasp it, the issue closes.
Delays such as the one that hit this title can usually be pinned to the artist, though with Williams, you can understand why it would take months for him to deliver a single issue. It’s not just that he has to capture the multitude of ideas Gaiman squeezes into a script; it’s that Williams does so as if he’s rendering one of the great masterworks of his life, which he may very well be doing. Every panel, character, and detail is crafted with loving care, each one unique and painstakingly drawn. There is no repetition or shortcut with Williams nor his collaborators. Stewart adds iridescent hues within every shade, and letterer Todd Klein finds new typographical voices for each and every single Dream.
Conclusion: Even for a beautifully crafted issue like this one, five months is a long time to wait, though Gaiman and Williams offer far more in one issue than many writers do in five.
Grade: B+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * And when I say musing, I don’t mean like the idle, random, often pointless thoughts that fill this section of the review.
– Cat Dream is fantastic, but I think I may love Robot Dream and Stone Totem Dream just as much. Or Superhero Dream. Or Clown Dream. It’s lovely to have choices of favorites, no?
Grade
Conclusion