By: Jeff Lemire (story), Mike McKone (art), Marcelo Maiolo (colors)

The Story: The Justice League does Canada.

The Review: It’s an interesting choice when a series starts with a #0 issue instead of a #1. What is that supposed to mean, exactly? If a #1 is properly understood to be the beginning of a story, then logically, a #0 must precede even the beginning. A prologue of sorts, then. Prologues are, at bottom, the essence of a beginning. A prologue is both teaser and cold open, the keyhole through which you can glimpse an outline of the larger story.

With that in mind, Lemire produces a functional, if not quite awe-inspiring, #0 issue. In short order, we get a flash of the story’s future stakes, appearances from all the principal characters, and the seeds of several plotlines. On a technical level, everything works fine; it’s just that nothing really moves you to that tingly feeling of excitement. That’s not a good sign from yet another series leeching off the Justice League name, even by the relatively small expectations of a prologue.

You’d feel a much greater pull toward the series had the chemistry of the characters produced more than a fizzle. The strongest interaction in the issue is Animal Man and Green Arrow’s riffs on who’s the lamer superhero, and even there, you feel they don’t really have their hearts in it. Buddy starts the fight out of thin air by remarking, “Foam arrow? And here I thought you were always the most ridiculous member of the JLA, Green Arrow. Way to prove me wrong.”

“I’m ridiculous?” Ollie snaps back. “Dude…you’re Animal Man!”

This rivalry between B-listers is a bit lame, but not unreasonable. In other instances, we’ve seen Ollie and Buddy reveal some insecurity over their lower-tier status in the DCU, so the uncalled-for ribbing here is just a snarky way to establish dominance. A lot of Lemire’s character choices are like this: credible, well thought-out, and somehow missing that little bit of genuineness to make it sing.

The big positive of the issue is Lemire’s reliance on classic sci-fi as the basis for the series. This whole mystery of aliens on Earth, gathering “specimens,” performing “grafts,” and speaking of “hybrids,” definitely plays with old and familiar ideas, but it’ll be interesting to see how they’re applied to the modern superhero. If nothing else, composing the team of so many space-farers and turning their gaze star-ward opens the series to a far wider range of possible threats than if they were focused only on their Canadian home base.

We might as well address that bit of oddness right now. It’s not clear why Lemire felt the need to set the title in the Great White North beyond national pride. With most of the team being Americans and Canada having no particularly outstanding space program, headquartering the League there seems unintuitive and counterproductive, change without any rhyme or reason.* Maybe Lemire will reveal some implausible, special reason why the team has to remain in Canada, but for now, even he can’t resist an obligatory “aboot” joke, and that’s about the extent of how he uses this unusual setting.

I remember McKone’s work quite fondly from his Teen Titans days, but what he’s doing here is quite different, and not necessarily in a good way, either. It looks simpler than it used to, the lines thinner, not quite as bold, perhaps the result of him inking his own pencils than having a collaborator like Marlo Alquiza on the job. Gone are the wide, cinematic shots and the tight, almost claustrophobic panels that he once excelled at, replaced by mostly views of the characters at a middle distance.

But I think coloring may be the biggest problem here. Marcelo’s pale washes look great on the flat, urban visuals of Green Arrow, but the Justice League calls for brighter, eye-popping hues and McKone’s figures need warmth to truly flourish. For what it is, the art is pleasant and shapely enough. Its only defect is not rising to the standard that it’s fully capable of.

Conclusion: There’s enough here to make the series intriguing, but it needs a much, much more to stand in the same sphere as its sister Justice League title.

Grade: B-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Heck, it’s not even clear why Animal Man and Stargirl are doing a press tour in Toronto in the first place, which is how this whole thing starts.

– In response to her friend’s teasing, Miiyahbin says dryly, “Ha ha—ever funny.” “Ever”? Is that a typo or a Canadianism I’ve never heard of?

Grade

Conclusion