
By: Al Ewing (story), Lee Garbett (art), Nolan Woodard (colors)
The Story: Who cons the con man?
The Review: Anybody here watch the Golden Globes? Remember last year’s ceremony, when Kristin Wiig and Will Ferrell did a bit where they pretended to have no idea who any of the nominees or their respective movies were? I laughed at the sheer silliness of it all until my eyes watered, and so was rather surprised to find people who not only didn’t laugh at the bit, but who didn’t think it was funny at all. Certainly Tommy Lee Jones didn’t.
The point of this story is that comedy strikes different people in vastly different ways, which makes it one of the tougher things to fairly evaluate. Who am I to say something is positively funny or unfunny? What strikes me as barely amusing can be a total crack-up to someone else. This is all to warn you to take my review here with as much salt as you can handle, because much of it has to do with Elwing’s particular comedic sensibilities.
It’s important to make it clear off the bat that Loki is not an all-out comedy, like Batman: Li’l Gotham or Harley Quinn, where almost every panel’s supposed to deliver a joke. As we see in this issue, there’s a real gravitas, even controversy, to what Loki’s doing for the All-Mother, and certainly his reasons for doing it are very, very serious. Mephisto’s reminder of Loki’s unforgivable crime is lighthearted, but Loki’s reaction couldn’t be less so. Unsurprisingly, it’s when that veneer of hipster wit falls away that Loki is at his most convincing, whether he’s coldly banishing Mephisto to protect his own secret, sending Sigurd to the All-Mother with real regret, or putting together his own team to break open the dungeons of Asgardia before he and the rest of the errant Asgardians are put there themselves.
Knowing that there’s such a calculating mind underneath all his salmon-cooking, video gaming, swash-and-buckling levity can’t help but make his humor seem a little insincere, or rather that he’s sincerely trying too hard to be humorous. That might be the essential difference between him and a character like Stephanie Brown, whose jokes are a natural part of her personality, whether she’s in costume or out, with any character in almost any context. Loki’s jokes are more a function of this new persona he’s trying to perpetuate. They’re not entirely a pretense, but they’re not entirely true to heart, either.
And that is where Elwing’s humor falls flat for me. Amusing they may be, but they also ring a little false, and you can frequently sense the sweat he’s putting in to get his laughs: the anachronistic snarks from both heroes (“Everyone loves the oldie-worldie talk when Thor does it.”) and villains (“…Cheap, penny-ante sleight-of-hand and a few tatty gimmicks.”); the random asides (“The secret is to take the skin off the salmon before cooking, then flash-fry it in lemon, oil, and a little salt until just crispy.”*); the wordplay which even Elwing acknowledges as tortured (“And part of your torment will involve a device I invented—as it rotates, it whips you with flowers made of horse bridles. It’s that kind of ‘Wheel of Rein Carnations.'”). Fortunately, Elwing doesn’t get too pushy with his jokes, which make them easy to smile at even if you don’t laugh out loud.
So while I may not be totally taken with Loki‘s comedy, I don’t see it as a dealbreaker. The more serious problem with the series is that it holds itself out as a mythic spy thriller, but so far has fallen flat in the spy and thriller areas. Loki’s battle with Sigurd mostly consists of an exchange of rhetorical barbs and a bit of weak swordplay, and his con of Mephisto requires little more ingenuity than a triple-layer of invisibility and not a little bit of retroactive plotting (“I switched the prayer mats while you were busy listening to Sigurd’s tale of derring-do.”). Where’s the challenge worthy of our god of mischief?
Garbett’s art is sleek and attractive, with Woodard using a mild palette along with just the right glows and sparks to keep things visually interesting. In terms of storytelling, Garbett doesn’t take many chances, but he does bring a lot of personality to the characters without turning them into cartoons, which is harder than you might think. Often, the issue’s best jokes are visual, like the eight-bit faces of the All-Mother appearing in the middle of Loki’s Space Invaders game (“Pew pew pew”) or Thor’s a-ha t-shirt.**
Conclusion: Entertaining enough, but for the flash and bang the series aims for, it should be so much more.
Grade: B-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * So basically, the secret is to sear the salmon. Brilliant!
** Of course Thor’s a fan of a-ha.
Grade
Conclusion