By: Geoff Johns (story), Ivan Reis & Doug Mahnke (pencils), Scott Hanna (inks), Rod Reis (colors)

The Story: The bar for League membership gets a lot lower.

The Review: The history of superhero comics is so long and involved that I seriously doubt any kind of plot that appears in the genre is truly original anymore. All I can say is Johns may be onto something we haven’t seen in a while with his latest vision of the Justice League. Secret traitors and double agents have been done before, but I don’t remember the last time known villains have joined a team of such repute as the League, especially one as notorious as Lex Luthor or as smalltime as Captain Cold.

Of course, your first thought at the very idea of Luthor joining the League is he’s got to be planning something. Make no mistake, he’s playing the game amazingly. “If there’s anything I want people to take away from the tragedy that befell our world,” he says in his first statement post-Forever Evil, “it’s that even with aliens, Amazons, and Atlanteans among us—a single human being can still make a difference. Police, firefighters and soldiers risk their lives every day to help others without the benefit of super-speed or a magic ring. I’m humbled to stand alongside those brave men and women.”

Clark is nonplussed. “Great answer if I believed any word of it was sincere.” As you might expect, no one, except that most exasperating of obstacles, the general public, is ignorant of Luthor’s character. And it’s inevitable his association with the League will go south eventually. But for now, he does reveal, under the sway of Diana’s lasso, a legitimate reason for joining them: “Because I’m an egomaniac,” and because “[w]hatever destroyed the Crime Syndicate’s world and forced them to flee here…it’s still out there. And together we’re the only ones who can stop it.”

Perhaps, but that doesn’t mean he has no other motive for pushing his way onto the team. Although he quietly acquiesces when they resist any suggestion of his membership, the fact that he then shows up on the doorstep of Wayne Manor, demanding that Alfred “tell Batman that Lex Luthor is here to see him,” means he really doesn’t give a crap what the League wants or thinks. Most importantly, Luthor’s knowledge of Bruce’s identity moves him dangerously close to the identities of the Bat-family and the other Leaguers.

While most of the issue is preoccupied with reestablishing the new status quo for the League, including adding Shazam to the team and paving the way for Cold’s membership, we do get a little bit of actual plot-building in the return of the Power Ring. The issue barely delves into the background of the ring’s newly chosen host, Jessica Cruz, but we do know she’s a disturbed woman who’s now been given the mission to “annihilate the Earth,” reopening questions about the ring’s nature and origins.

What I really enjoy about Reis’ approach to drawing characters is he can make them look attractive without sculpting them, as if they were manufactured with immaculate proportion in a Swiss factory. Reis’ characters are looser, more flexible, their movements light and natural instead of stiff like the action figure poses that his peers often come up with. But Reis can still stand to learn a few things, even from his co-penciller. Mahnke’s characters may lack the supermodel looks of Reis’, but they’re even more distinctive as a result, with more potent, meaningful expressions than Reis is capable of.

Conclusion: A very slow issue, but one that promises to change not only the composition of the League, but its entire dynamic.

Grade: B-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – The newest set of Doom Patrol members seems to be the classic one. I see silhouettes of Negative Man and Robot Man behind the standing Niles Caulder, and there are two women with them, one who may be Elasti-Girl.

–

Grade

Conclusion