By: Al Ewing (story), Lee Garbett (art), Nolan Woodard (colors)

The Story: Loki finds himself and realizes he was better off lost.

The Review: For the purposes of discussion, let’s all agree that right now, Loki has one big secret: the murder of his younger self, the “crime that will not be forgiven.” True, he’s confessed it to his Young Avenger pals, but it’s a bit like dealing with your newfound atheism or homosexuality. You can proudly flaunt it to everyone else in the world, but as long as you keep it from your Bible-worshipping, you’ll always feel a little bit trapped.

Loki will be feeling especially so after this issue, now that he’s discovered the goblin-ish Loki scheming from the wings is not a manifestation of his past self, but his future. We’ve all known the real conflict in the series would come to this: the Loki trying to change versus the Loki who loves who he is. It bodes ill for the ultimate outcome of the battle that older Loki completely outmaneuvers younger Loki here. Able to freely traverse the past and see into the future, older Loki can shut down the younger’s plan of attack before he even conceives of it. It’s a foregone conclusion.

Even more horrifying is the All-Mother’s unfeeling approval of all this. In a scenario that calls one to mind of Ursula K. Le Guin’s seminal short story, “The Ones Who Walk Away from Omelas,” the All-Mother can accept Loki’s eventual descent into villainy in exchange for a happy ending for the rest of Asgard. While Loki is doomed to play “the recurring villain, always scheming, always beaten with no harm done,” the rest of Asgard gets the peace and security of knowing their fate, “without the horrors of Ragnarok.” The cruelest line of all: “Only you saw chains, Loki.” So everyone else gets to change their story, just not the one who wants to the most. As his older self crows, “I am the destiny you run from—but will never escape! Because nobody else wants you to!”

Yet maybe there’s a seed of hope in that proclamation. If Loki can’t escape his destiny because nobody wants him to, then conversely, he can escape if people do. But for that, Loki will probably have to lay out the whole truth about himself. Older Loki may be cruel, but he’s not lying when he mocks his younger self for hiding from who he really is. As long as Loki continues to avoid his gravest sin, the gravity of that act will always pull him back. It’s up to him to expose that unforgivable crime and see if anyone else will forgive it anyway.

I’m a sucker for redemption stories, so I wish him the best of luck, even though the reformed Loki is admittedly duller than his more frenetic, older counterpart. Again, Elwing had the right idea in reframing the god of mischief as a lovable trickster instead of egomaniacal villain, but the tricks we’ve seen thus far have been largely couched in poorly founded twists (e.g., Loki and Sigurd’s dumpster deal) or deus ex machina-like gadgets that Elwing devises out of thin air (e.g., Lorelei’s “Charm of Liquid Solids. Fresh from the quantum-forges of the Matter-Smiths of Nidavellir”). What should be the greatest heist-mission ever—penetrating the impenetrable of Asgard—turns out to be a very simple job. Ocean’s Eleven, it ain’t—nor even Ocean’s Twelve or Thirteen.


While this issue offers proof positive that Garbett is a bit helpless in drawing women who look different from each other, he’s really surpassing himself in all other respects. Great as his work on Batgirl was, Loki provides him far more opportunities to show how far his talent reaches. Never would I have thought he could pull off a double-splash of Thor facing off against a massive, techno-creature in space, but it looks pretty epic here, especially in the unsettlingly organic design of the creature, its many mechanical limbs stretching out like the cancerous limbs of a tumor. Kudos also to Woodard’s surreal, pale green and reds, heightening the Technocracy’s* unearthly vibe.

Conclusion: The great metafictional tensions of the third act almost make up for the lame heist that dominates most the issue, and there’s strong art throughout.

Grade: B

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * It’s a little irritating, by the way, that Elwing just drags this thing from nowhere, without a bit of explanation of what it is and where it comes from other than an editor’s note to Mighty Avengers #9.

– Does it really take a prophecy to know that Sigurd and Lorelei’s relationship is going to end tragically? Older Loki might as well prophesize the tragic end of Kimye. It’s gonna happen.

Grade

Conclusion