By: Scott Snyder (story), Sean Murphy (art), Matt Hollingsworth (colors)

The Story: Leeward discovers that Captain for a Day is as much a jip as the queen version.

The Review: For a very brief period of time in my college days, I was editor of a hopeful (soon to be hopeless) literary magazine. The work was thankless and the pay was pitiful—good practice for a future in comic book reviewing, honestly—but I enjoyed it, nonetheless. I learned that a good editor wields his power rarely, pushing the writing only when it doesn’t do what the writer wants it to do. Giving creators their freedom is great and all, but you have to step in if they’re not living up to their own standards.

Were I editor of The Wake, I probably would’ve stepped in somewhere around #6
or #7 and gently (but firmly) told Snyder and Murphy, “You’ve got to give this more than ten issues. You’ve gone through the painstaking trouble of crafting this brand new world—you drew a map, for heaven’s sake—and there’s absolutely no way you’re going to explore any of it, drive it to ruin, then save it in the issues you have left. Or, more accurately, there is a way, but it’s not going to be pretty.” If Snyder and Murphy are anything like the writers I worked with, they’ll nod politely and ignore me anyway, then give me resentfully chagrined looks if it turns out I was right: it wasn’t pretty, as it is here.

With Leeward having only just taken off with Captain Mary to find Lee Archer on the very last page of #8, it’s a bit stunning to find the crew of the Argo 3 already arrived at their destination, three months later. Snyder has little choice, sticking adamantly to his ten-issue limit, but it’s a deep disappointment anyway. Imagine if Scheherazade had ended one night with the tale of Sinbad starting his first voyage, then took up the story the next night with him about to finish his seventh. King Shahryar probably would’ve ended up executing her after all.

There is little of Snyder’s usually calm, elegant prose here. To give us some idea of Leeward and Mary’s adventures during those unseen months, he resorts to that old standby of writers who’re too much in a hurry to craft a proper narrative: a summarized list. In two pages, we get passing mentions to the tribal Bogong, who feed on the Mer, and the “Tru Nudes of Oman, who bind and trap their own bodies inside machines when they’re young, so they never grow any bigger than the bodies of children.” And that’s pretty much all she wrote on the matter.

For those who were eager to cut to the chase, you have your own letdowns. Even though Leeward comes across the cave drawings of “The Storyteller” we saw 100,000 years ago in #1, they’re no more comprehensible now than they were then, even though we get a full glimpse of his mural. Leeward picks up a couple interesting, unidentifiable objects, but before we even get a chance to speculate on what they are, the action makes a sudden spike, resulting in the rather anticlimactic death of Mary, the destruction of the Argo 3, and the descent of Leeward into the deeps. It all happens very quickly; had this been a movie, it would’ve been over in a couple minutes, and it feels even faster here.

Even with so many pacing and substance problems, Snyder’s writing is never less than fully competent and intriguing, and thankfully, he has Murphy on his side to make the most of every short scene. The annihilation of the Argo 3 might take place in a single panel, but it’s preceded by a double-splash of Vivienne’s amassed army, chocked to the brim with ships and aircraft,* all lovingly, distinctively drawn. Murphy didn’t just take a few models and have Hollingsworth slap some different coats of paint on them; each ship, plane, and blimp has its own structural design, posing all kinds of questions (sure to be unanswered) about their origins.

Conclusion: The writing’s solid; the art’s superb; but the pacing and substance are so thin that you can’t help coming away from the issue somewhat dissatisfied.

Grade: B-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Which goes to show how desperate she is to shut down Leeward, which makes me more eager than ever to see her go down in flames—literally ones, if at all possible.

– It’s wonderful to see that whatever spirit world Leeward ended up in, Dash is with her. Least he deserves.

Grade

Conclusion