By: Charles Soule (story), Tony Daniel (pencils), Matt Banning & Sandu Florea (inks), Tomev Morey (colors)

The Story: Never ask an Amazon to do a god’s work.

The Review: I feel safe with you guys, so I’m just gonna let it all out: I don’t know how much more of this I can stand. It’s true that my general distaste for Doomsday made me predisposed to dislike Doomed, but I don’t think I’m out of line for saying that the storyline has been an overlong bit of mindless drivel so far. When you have four ongoing titles involved in a crossover, and the story still feels like it’s going nowhere, that’s unacceptable.

Anyway, don’t take my word for it. The repetitiousness of Doomed is obvious in this issue alone, in which once again Clark has a tiresome dialogue with himself—his Doomsday self, that is—and various well-meaning individuals attempt to put him down, only to irritate him further. It’s enough to make you wonder where everyone’s brains went. It’s one thing for Guy Gardner to throw himself into battle without thinking, but you’d think women as intelligent as Hessia or Supergirl would be better than that.

Unfortunately not. Hessia tries to justify her attack on Clark by calling him a threat to the world—then she baits him into proving her point. Kara attacks her cousin from behind without warning, and when he responds with prejudice, she cries, “Stop, Kal! What are you doing?” There’s not much logic going on here, but that’s to be expected from people deluded enough to think that some fancy armor and a couple Red Lanterns are enough to stop a Superman-Doomsday hybrid.

I can’t imagine why a writer with Soule’s intelligence would write characters who act so unintelligently, unless he, too, is at a loss for what to do with this storyline. There is a distinctly cheap quality to the dialogue that you don’t normally associate with Soule. Whether it’s Kara inane mutterings to herself (“[Clark’s]…stronger now and there’s something in the air– I feel weak… Kryptonite..? Can we stop him? I’m not sure—”) or Diana’s unnecessary bluntness (“You are bound to speak only the truth,” she tells a lassoed Guy), you get the distinct sense that Soule’s just killing time.

Ultimately, this issue only gives us two bits we can make use of: the admittedly surprising revelation that Hessia exposed Clark and Diana’s relationship to the world, and the possibility of the Red Lanterns lending their expertise to help Clark control his darker half. But these are small offerings for the price of admission, and they’re only barely supplemented by the spectacle of Hessia, in magic armor, taking on Clark before Diana, in god mode, intervenes.

Daniel certainly makes these battles look as impressive as possible, and as far as I’m concerned, he can draw god-Diana as often as he wants. But I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again: no amount of artistry can make a weak story a great one. Daniel does his best; even though he’s not really the most emotional of artists, he’s pretty convincing here, giving Hessia a rather fantastic intensity and Diana the sensitivity she often lacks in her face elsewhere.

Conclusion: Pretty pictures; forgettable story. I’m very tempted to go on hiatus with these titles until Doomed is over. Stay tuned.

Grade: C

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Does anyone else remember a Wonder Woman storyline involving Circe in which Clark gets partially turned into Doomsday? I get a lot of déjà vu from seeing Clark with rocky crags on his face and Diana trying to stop him.

– Woah—Guy has changed quite a bit since I saw him last…longer hair, the facial hair…

– And the award for Least Convincing Romantic Banter goes to Diana and Clark for this cringingly corny exchange:

“We’ve only gone dancing once.”

“And I didn’t even show you my best moves.”

“You know, it did feel like you were holding back.”

“…I will come back to you.”

“I know, darling. Go.”

Grade

Conclusion