
By: Dan Slott (story), Michael Allred (art), Laura Allred (colors)
The Story: To save the universe, Silver Surfer calls upon the powers of Larry, Curly, and Moe.
The Review: I’ve never much liked characters who had too many powers at their disposal, and Marvel definitely has a big share of them. From a storytelling standpoint, these kinds of characters just make things harder for the writer. It’s pretty hard to devise serious challenges for people like the Phoenix, Thor, or the Hulk, and even when you do, the power levels are so high that the story risks spilling out over the top. Superpowers too easily become an all-purpose tool in a character’s belt.
Take Norrin and his Power Cosmic, whose deus ex machina qualities make it virtually indistinguishable from magic. In this issue alone, Norrin uses the Power Cosmic to disguise himself, shield Dawn from the freezing vacuum of space, distract all of the Impericon’s guardsmen, and keep the entire pleasure planet running long enough for all its denizens to escape. The sheer utility of his powers causes Dawn to remark, somewhat uncomfortably, “That’s very…convenient.”
“That’s the Power Cosmic,” Norrin replies. It’s okay for him to take an easy win at this early juncture, but I’m a little worried about the future. No one’s really interested in reading a series where our hero meets and defeats ninety percent of his challenges with silver-golden rays of abstract power. I mean, how often is Norrin going to run into someone with even greater power, like the Never Queen, or who just so happens to have Power Cosmic-nullifying armor, like Zed?
But these are concerns for future stories. For now, it’s enough that Zed’s armor does push Norrin to rely on his wits to defeat the double-mouthed alien. Ideally, there would’ve been some struggle involved, a little bit of playing around before Norrin finishes the job with his Three Stooges eye-poke (the man actually nyuks—I kid you not),* but as is, the scene plays pretty well. If nothing else, it definitively proves that we’re no longer dealing with Silver Surfer, the melancholy ex-herald of Galactus, but Norrin Radd, a much more colorful man.
If the Three Stooges slapstick didn’t make it clear, Slott’s Silver Surfer is meant to be a kooky affair, a screwball comedy with cosmic overtones. It’s not sophisticated, but it’s rather endearing for its sweetly innocent delivery: Norrin turning up the dramatics to get the Impericon’s visitors to evacuate (“Lo and behold! I am the Silver Surfer! And I am devouring your planet!
Run for your lives!“); the manifestation of the Never Queen’s heart as a toy monkey; Dawn mistaking the name of Norrin’s surfboard as “Toomie” when he was actually saying, “To me, my board!” Silly, but at least it never feels like Slott’s desperately trying to be funny.
To complement the somewhat childish humor, there’s a fairy tale flavor to the series’ sci-fi in Slott’s fanciful narration. The Never Queen steals a kiss with her true love, Eternity, in “a space outside of time, and a time outside of space,” only to be interrupted by “an incredulous man with an unreal sword,” given to Zed by a mysterious benefactor from “the Lands of Couldn’t-Be-Shouldn’t Be.” At one point, Zed even asks the Never Queen if his destiny is to “live wealthily ever after[.]” But this is a story that began with a wish upon a star, which calls for a little more magic than your typical space opera.
Allred’s assertive linework is a great foil for Slott’s whimsical script. The simplicity and boldness of Allred’s style makes the visuals look like the artistic cousin of Javier Pulido, but where Pulido merely suggests the soapish elements of old-timey comic strips, Allred embraces it completely. His characters don’t have the emotionally excessive expressions as those strips did, but that same heightened drama runs through all of Allred’s panels. Laura Allred’s palette of Easter egg colors would make the issue look too mild by half, but she uses them as a sharp contrast to the primary colors of the featured characters: the New Queen’s grassy green, Dawn’s ladybug dress and indigo hair, Norrin’s bluish-silver. This is storybook art for a storybook tale
Conclusion: I can think of worse series to invest in than a modern-day, sci-fi fairy tale, especially one that’s written and drawn with such cheeky warmth.
Grade: B+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * And how wonderful that this is one of his big takeaways from Earth. It figures that the biggest influence our planet would have on extraterrestrials would be something stupid.
– “Look, everyone just assumes since I have a giant brain for a head that I know what I’m talking about.” Mr. Mygdalla may be the true hero of this issue.
Grade
Conclusion