![]()
By: Geoff Johns (story), Doug Mahnke (pencils), Keith Champagne & Christian Alamy (inks), Rod Reis (colors)
The Story: What to do when your secret identity’s discovered.
The Review: I’ve heard somewhere that Johns is not a big Batman fan, but I think it’s more accurate to say that he doesn’t worship Batman the way many superhero readers do. People have built up Batman’s stature to the point that he sometimes coming across as less human than his actually inhuman peers. This goes against Johns’ grain, since he’s a writer who likes to bring characters down to Earth in an occasionally misguided attempt to make them more “relatable.”
Perhaps this explains why Batman in Johns’ hands is hardly the mighty figure we’re used to seeing. Compared to the vicious Batman who appears in the works of Scott Snyder or Pete Tomasi, Johns’ Batman is mostly hot air, a bit flimsier and more ineffectual. We saw this in his laughable attempts maintain control in Forever Evil, and we see it again here as he tries to fake his way out of Luthor’s discovery of his identity: “I don’t know what you’re talking about, Luthor. I’m not Batman.” The only way he could be more unconvincing would be to add a stutter and several exclamation points.
As it stands, Bruce and Alfred mishandle the situation quite badly, from Alfred’s guilt-sealing expression of shock when Luthor showed up on Wayne Manor’s doorstep, to Bruce leading Lex into the very room where his secret cave entrance is located, to Bruce pulling off a masterful flying leap and roundhouse kick when Luthor refuses to be denied. For someone who’s spent a good chunk of his life cultivating an oblivious playboy persona, it just falls apart when confronted by the smartest man in the DCU.
Anyway, once the secret’s out for good, Bruce manages to regain some of his crisp dignity. Despite his compromising position, he refuses to negotiate with Luthor and even comes close to delivering a good comeback by adding his personal twist to the classic frog and scorpion fable: “Halfway across the river, just as the scorpion’s about to sting the frog…a bat flies by…and rips the scorpion into the sky…then dines on it while the frog swims away.” In this case, the frog is the League; the scorpion’s Luthor; and the bat is obvious.
Interesting as it’ll be to see how Luthor will deal with such obstinacy, the League has a more pressing concern in the Power Ring choosing Jessica Cruz as its newest host. Johns handles her with surprising sensitivity. Though she has good reasons for fearing the world outside, she’s no coward—not that it matters. Her outright refusal of the ring only results in her being made its unwilling captive, which can only go one of three ways: (a) the League mentors her willpower to tame the ring to good; (b) her fragile psychology eventually gives way to the ring’s corrupting influence and she becomes the very thing she fears; (c) the League gets rid of the ring and Jessica returns to her life, wiser and braver. None of the options are great, but I’d say the first has the most potential for being somewhat novel.
Johns isn’t so much a character writer as a writer of character moments. You’ll have issues where nearly the whole thing is full of people behaving just as you’d predict them to, and then you’ll have one great scene right in the middle. For this issue, that scene is Billy complaining about the boredom of monitor duty to a patient Vic, who’s never better than in a big brother role. Luthor’s discovery of Bruce’s identity is a big deal, of course, but Billy entreating Vic to play the X-Box in Vic’s left shoulder and then magically summoning a Ping-Pong table into their HQ actually feels like something you haven’t seen before.
Mahnke’s style is less open, conventionally attractive, and glorious than Ivan Reis’ work, but that’s only to say that Mahnke puts in far more personality into his art. Physical features are sharpened, coming ever so shy of exaggeration: the squareness of the League men’s jaws, Alfred’s narrow eyes and thin-bladed nose, the titanic expanse of Clark’s chest. It’s at once less realistic yet more immersive than Reis’ art; there’s a raw quality to Mahnke’s work that pulls you in where you might slide off more polished visuals. Rod Reis understands that, and his colors are appropriately more muted than usual, though its gleaming textures remain intact.
Conclusion: Some questionable choices of characterization, but a solid read, plot-wise.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Snart’s none too bright; why you’d allow anyone as unethical and innovative as Luthor take a sample of your blood is beyond me.
– Classic Doom Patrol! Plus Element Woman. I’m excited, even if I’m not sure what they can do against the likes of Power Ring.
Grade
Conclusion