By: Jeff Lemire (story), Mike McKone (art), Cam Smith & Guillermo Ortego (inks), Marcelo Maiolo & Andrew Dalhouse (colors)

The Story: Dealing with a traumatized child is a lot easier if you have psychic powers.

The Review: Last month, I suggested that Justice League United may be the least enjoyable part of Justice League United, which I meant only partly in jest. Acknowledging that team chemistry is probably a difficult thing to generate from scratch, it must be said that the JLU has very little of it. That’s not totally unnatural, given how new the team is and how unformed their personalities are, but it does make for a duller read, and there seems to be little improvement in that respect on the horizon.

Lemire’s so distracted with carrying the plot forward that we get few interactions among the cast in the first place that isn’t exposition-related, and what few we do have rise to a very tepid degree of liveliness. After Kara socks Lobo into the stratosphere, Buddy remarks, “Wow. Nice punch, kid.”

“Hey, what about my arrow?” Ollie complains, referring to the shaft he just earlier put into Lobo’s shoulder.*

Buddy, unbothered: “Meh.”

And that’s about as exciting as it gets with the team itself. Even a slight power struggle between J’onn and Carter fails to produce sparks. J’onn simply shuts it down by asserting his former League leadership, which is a great moment for him, but which also makes Carter, supposedly one of DC’s biggest badasses, seem meeker than ever.

Even though Lemire’s writing two characters he’s had ongoing experience with, J’onn is his clear favorite. The Martian’s quiet force comes through in every issue, but so does his capacity for sympathy, making him the closest thing to a well-rounded character JLU has. This, along with his versatile powers, frequently leads him to nearly take over the title, but at least that makes him memorable.

The same can’t be said for anyone else in the series, particularly Meeyahbin,** whose existence Lemire desperately tries to remind us of each month. Of course, it’d be easier to keep her in mind if she was actually part of the main storyline, but so far, she’s been relegated to 2-3 page scenes that repeatedly expose her to the horror of the Whitago without actually fleshing out that threat. Anyway, it’s all soon overshadowed by the sci-fi zaniness that makes up the rest of the issue.

Again, if this was a committed Adam Strange, cosmic adventure-type series, you’d be more inclined to enjoy the Zeta Beam malfunctions and accelerated growth of Ultra as a space opera pastiche. But the presence of the JLU makes the already simple plot even more straightforward and predictable. J’onn’s psychic powers makes communion with Ultra a snap, and once Carter volunteers to fly out the damaged Zeta core before it destroys Rannagar, it no longer poses a threat—not even to him. Supergirl may exclaim that he’s dead as dramatically as she wants, but Lemire couldn’t have revealed Carter’s regrown arm just to kill him off an issue later.***

To make the issue’s mediocrity complete, McKone continues his unenthusiastic work, patiently delivering art that just stands there, looking pretty, without bringing any life into the room. To see what I mean, take a look at the panel where Ollie shoots an arrow into Lobo’s shoulder, which produces no reaction from Lobo whatsoever—fine; Lobo’s not the type to be fazed by an arrow anyway. But in the very next panel, the arrow’s suddenly exploding in his hand, as if we skipped a transition panel somewhere, and by exploding, I mean a soft flurry of color that seems to surprise rather than bother the alien bounty hunter. It’s the very definition of dull.

Grade: C+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * And apparently, Ollie has fallen onto such hard times that he can’t even spare the loss of one explosive arrow anymore.

** Wait—wasn’t it Miiyahbin?

*** Anyway, death didn’t exactly stop Carter over in Futures End either, from what I hear.

Grade

Conclusion