
By: Scott Snyder (story), Sean Murphy (art), Matt Hollingsworth (colors)
The Story: It’s only near the end of the world that we learn the Scientologists were right all along.
The Review: As of last issue, we still had no idea what the hell was going on in this series. We didn’t know where the Mers came from or what they wanted, how Lee Archer managed to send a message to Leeward from the dead, and how she was planning to save the world. Snyder has left those ends wide open; needless to say, he has a lot
to explain in this issue, and it’s almost guaranteed there’ll still be points left unresolved at the end.
Much to his credit, however, Snyder manages to tie every vague vignette from every past issue together into a cohesive revelation that actually manages to be revelatory, astonishingly so. Of course, you’ll have to read between his metaphors (ladders and seeds feature heavily in this issue) to get the answers you seek, but at least they’re relatively straightforward and mostly satisfying. [Warning: major spoilers ahead! Read on at your own risk!]
Humans are the aliens. That’s the big secret. Put that bluntly, it sounds a little silly, but Snyder actually delivers it with a good amount of suspense and craft. This is what you can understand: a seed was sent to Earth during its prehistoric era. “Sometimes the seed,” says Lee, “it doesn’t take. Sometimes it’s just a disaster and it kills what’s there.” She’s referring to the fate of Mars, I assume. But on Earth, that seed took root and eventually grew to become our Neanderthal forbears. At that point, the people who sent the seed—what we call humans—arrive, presumably once they’re assured the planet can sustain their kind of lifeform. Upon arrival, the seedlings are destroyed, the advanced technology left to degrade, and the people’s memories of being from anywhere other than Earth erased—by our very tears, no less.
Okay—mind blown. The weaving of scientific theory into this utterly fantastical yarn gives Lee’s story the essence of a fairy tale, but it’s also haunting in how much sense it makes. What we thought was a series about undersea monsters and their vendetta against humanity suddenly becomes one where humanity is truly the invader and the “monsters” are merely trying to secure their home.
At least, that’s what you assume. To be honest, once Snyder starts getting carried away with his new origin of species, the Mers become a secondary consideration. Their value is in forcing us visitors to remember where we came from and think about going back. But in the end, they only partly accomplish that task. Lee has led a group to unknown parts of space, searching for where they came from, but most of humanity, including Leeward, is still on Earth. And yet the Mers seem quite satisfied with this; by the end of the issue, we see Leeward sailing happy and free on the open seas, with a school of Mers leaping playfully out of the water beside her, not unlike Dash.
Other points are left rather vague. To the end, we never quite understand what Vivienne was up to. That she wanted to keep the last remaining ship of humanity’s earliest ancestors either sunken or shut down is clear. Why is less so. Perhaps she’s just one of the people who reacted badly to the unknown, as Lee says some people do if they manage to remember they don’t belong here. Perhaps all she wanted to do was maintain her power. Who knows? And as to how and why the Mers kept people like Lee alive for so long, Snyder offers an explanation* but it’s obvious that it’s irrelevant next to the story he really wants to tell.
There are sci-fi wonders worthy of a blockbuster film in this issue; I’m talking Contact material here. Thank goodness Snyder has Murphy to draw it all; he’s one of the few artists who can truly convey a cinematic scale in a comic book page. That splash of the final ship, massive beyond belief, perfectly circular, studded with blinking lights, rising from the sea and making Vivienne’s air and sea force look like ant-sized paper planes and ships beside it, nearly takes your breath away.
Conclusion: Amazingly enough, Snyder delivers nearly as good of an end as you can hope for, albeit at the cost of an occasionally disappointing whole.
Grade: A-
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * “The creatures keep us alive when they bring us, oxygenating our blood, through the skin, things called spinners…It’s designed to keep us alive, in stasis. The gases in the air prevent replicative senescence.” Okay, fine.
– Dash is alive and well. And Vivienne’s dead. That’s all I care about.
Grade
Conclusion