By: Too many to list—check out the review.

The Story: Superman returns.

The Review: About a month ago, I decided to stick to Doomed despite many misgivings about the storyline. It was a close call, however. Part of what kept me onboard was the resignation that the event was nearly over anyway. A few more issues, I could handle. Had I known the Doomed showrunners planned to add two annuals to the mix, I probably would have reconsidered my commitment. Annuals are costly things, and the thought of putting that much more money into Doomed was hard to take.

On the plus side, the annuals confirm that what we thought was a Doomsday story is actually a Brainiac one, which is an improvement, sort of. It seems somewhat repetitive to make the villain yet again the center of a major Superman story (the last time being one of Superman’s earliest big adventures); can’t they come up with someone else to challenge our hero? Must we always turn to the usual suspects? Shouldn’t there be at least a three year moratorium on a supervillain after he’s been featured in a major story arc?

Superhero ennui aside, the story does take on a massive scale as the Justice League finally takes notice of the disaster descending upon them. Not that it really matters. Within a few panels, their elaborate defense systems are completely ripped apart and their physical efforts prove to be largely ineffective until Clark—or should I say Superdoom*–shows up to steal everyone’s thunder. As if Hawkman and Simon Baz as Green Lantern haven’t already been marginalized enough, Charles Soule depicts them uselessly flailing against the enemy’s preliminary forces so that Clark can bail them out.

Clark’s intervention nearly proves disastrously counterproductive, but of course there was never a real possibility of any irredeemable consequences. Bruce inevitably succeeds in removing the impediment to Clark maintaining control of his transformation—although we never see it, as that plotline takes place in Action Comics Annual #3. As a result, Bruce’s timely victory almost has the instantaneous effect of a deus ex machina, allowing Clark to have full use of his faculties when the big papa boss shows up.

Among the saving graces of the issue is the treatment of Lana and Diana, both of whom are crucial to the heroes’ successes in this issue. As awesome as it is to see Diana in god-mode kicking Superdoom’s butt, I’d say the more impressive feat is Lana using her electrical engineering expertise to deduce what Brainiac is up to, providing the foundation of their counterattack. If any character actually profits from this storyline, it’ll be those two.

Despite the hodgepodge of artists working on the issue, the results are surprisingly consistent. Ed Benes and Tony Daniel are the heavier hitters, with unashamedly bold, sexy styles, but Pascal Alixe, Cliff Richards, and Jack Herbert are no slouches either. The storytelling is utterly conventional and the action sequences are at best decent, but they get the job done; as the issue progresses, you do get a sense of the global stakes at play.

Conclusion: A mindlessly entertaining action-fest that’s largely predictable, but occasionally worthwhile.

Grade: C+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Still the dumbest name I can think of.

– At one point, Cyborg reports that Black Canary and someone named “Condor” is down. Which Condor is this?

– “Lana, I—” Steel begins.

“What, John?”

“…I’ll tell you when I get back.” Sounds like a romantic confession is in the works. I can get behind that relationship, if it works out.

Grade

Conclusion