By: Jeff Lemire (story), Mike McKone (art), Cam Smith (inks), Marcelo Maiolo (colors)

The Story: Nothing like opposing dimensional polarities to put a crimp in the marriage.

The Review: So we’ve come to Justice League United‘s fourth issue, and as some of you may know, that means it’s time to decide whether to stick to the series or leave it by the wayside. I’ll cut to the chase: I’m not buying it. JLU just doesn’t really stand out in a market that’s lately crowded with ambitious and unusual concepts. It’s pretty much how I feel about In ‘n’ Out: I like it fine, but there are new burgers in the neighborhood that I’m more excited to try.

On the most basic level, JLU‘s cast has little chemistry going for it. The situation’s a bit like the early days of Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D., in which the characters woodenly played their archetypical roles for months. Eventually, things clicked together, but what a drag while it lasted. That’s exactly the word you’d use to describe the character interaction in this issue: a drag. Lemire labors to inject tension into the issue; the problem is you can see the sweat involved.

You have J’onn stubbornly taking the blame for Carter’s death, even though there was no way he could have predicted the Zeta Beam’s explosive malfunction—and anyway, we all know Carter will be back pretty soon, if not within the next issue or so. You also have Kara berating Courtney’s innocent attempt to bond,* just because Courtney made the mistake of referring to “aliens” around her. While overtly a criticism of Courtney’s youth and naivety, it’s mostly a display of Kara’s brittle personality.

And then there’s Ollie and Buddy, whose completely artificial rivalry has been a weight on JLU from the start. While you’re glad to see them moving past that in this issue, they do so for almost the wrong reasons. Ollie may be the bigger man here, offering his condolences on the death of Buddy’s son and admitting he’s not used to this team thing, but that’s a big fat lie if you ever heard one. Having tried countless times to join the Justice League with a groupie’s desperation, then operating in the JLA with perfect professionalism, it’s illogical to blame his behavior on lone-wolfism. It’s not like he gets in J’onn, Kara, Carter, Adam, or even Courtney’s faces the way he does with Buddy. Mutual insecurity would have been the better explanation for Buddy and Ollie’s acrimony, but perhaps that’s too deep a revelation for this stage of their relationship (“I think this is where we hug it out,” Buddy says, smirking, after their talk).

The other fundamental problem with JLU is the vagueness of its mission statement, which is basically saying that it’s not very original. J’onn declares that he wants the nascent team needs to be an “example of true heroism, selflessness, sacrifice,” to avoid aligning with any one government, and to “represent heroes coming together.” So what makes them different from the Justice League proper, besides a slightly more diverse line-up?

Lemire might claim the JLU’s interstellar activities set it apart from other Leagues, but from what we’ve seen, the title only pays lip-service to the space opera genre and is run-of-the-mill superhero the rest of the time. It’s a real pity, too; as I’ve said before, if this was a series starring just Adam and Alanna Strange** and their outer space adventures, we might have something valuable on our hands. Instead, the Stranges are relegated to background support, speaking up only to sigh about the sorry state of their romance.

The issue is nearly all talking-heads, which means more of McKone’s pleasantly attractive but utterly conventional work. There’s a little hope in the few action sequences, however. That one close-up of Miiyahbin transforming and breaking out of her icy restraints comes closest to the McKone of old, making the newest Canadian hero look quite impressive. I’m also more convinced than ever that Maiolo’s shiny glosses doesn’t work well with McKone’s soft, dimensional figures; the matted surfaces in Alanna’s scenes feel more natural than the slightly plastic tone in the rest of the issue.

Conclusion: You sense that Lemire will eventually figure out what makes the characters and this team tick. Unfortunately, that’s something he should’ve gotten around to in this first arc. Dropped.

Grade: C+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Makes you wonder when those variant covers of Courtney, Kara, and Miiyahbin taking selfies and attending hockey games will actually come true.

** Yup, they apparently eloped—which you’d care more about if you actually saw more of them as a couple beforehand

*** See, I thought it was Miiyahbin. Guess it was a typo last time.

Grade

Conclusion