
By: Charles Soule (story), Jesus Saiz (art), Matt Hollingsworth (colors)
The Story: Another skill Alec needs as avatar of the Green? Business negotiation.
The Review: I’ve never really taken the opportunity to talk about how much we lucked out when Soule took over this series, but that was a fortuitous thing, no joke. It’s rare for a creative changeover to not only be smooth, but an improvement on what came before, especially when what came before was pretty good to begin with. Soule has made Swamp Thing more consistently entertaining and smarter both than Scott Snyder’s run; what are the chances of it happening again?
For all of his contributions to the mythos, however, lately Soule’s relying quite heavily on the old trick of creating new kingdoms to contend with the Green, which risks wearing it out. Soule probably eked out the last drop of surprise factor when he introduced the Grey, which had a pretty limited role and impact despite the significance of its existence. With the Divided and the Metal, kingdoms foretold in the Futures End crossover, Soule will have to work harder to sell their necessity.
Honestly, I don’t know if choosing the Metal for his next kingdom was the best choice. It’s radically different from the others, to be sure, but its source and position in the natural world is obscure at best. With machines, we’re talking about something artificial and man-made, with far less penetration than plants, animals, decay, and fungi. Besides, despite an outstanding narrative on how a single “impulse” eventually evolved into a complex logical system, it’s really no different from all the other stories where artificial intelligence rose up to assert its power.
So Soule has work to do still on shaping the Metal, but you can at least admire the craft he puts into the work. There’s a natural flow and enthusiasm to his prose in Swamp Thing that’s lacking in the writing for his other projects. In those issues, he frequently has to grind at the script until he snaps into a groove, but here, he enters grooving:
“An impulse follows a set of instructions, a program. If these conditions exist, then turn right. If other conditions exist, then turn left. These are the only options. If this, then that. If that, then this. But there is another path. One blocked by a logic gate that could not be opened. There was no if that would lead to a then in that direction. But over time, the impulse became aware of connections being made behind the gate. Other impulses. Interacting. Making a sort of ordered noise. The impulse wanted to hear that noise. To be part of it. And so…the impulse made its own if.”
Even Soule’s dialogue has an easy rhythm absent from She-Hulk, Superman/Wonder Woman, or Letter 44. That’s a feat in itself, considering the Metal’s avatar speaks in an interesting jumble of reason (“Monsters and pretenders and monsters again, all while trying to maintain a complex system that you barely understand, because you are forced to rely on just your single human mind.”), colloquialism (“You can have it, bud. Don’t got one, don’t need one.”), and pop culture references (“It ain’t easy being Green.”). It goes against the grain of so many hyper-logical depictions of A.I., which makes it an interesting character choice.
Even if Soule leaves, can we hope for Saiz to stay on board? As great as the writing of the opening pages are, they pack a punch because Saiz figured out how to put Soule’s logical language into a corresponding visual we can easily understand: a bead of light traveling along a simple grid, leading into a complex web of lines, which borders the natural networks of the other kingdoms. And there’s something wonderful about DC putting an artist with some of the most beautiful work on a title like this. Saiz’s design for the Metal’s agent is perfect, its smooth metallic face in a crisp-cut suit an unsettling blend of human mimicry and inhumanness.
Conclusion: Very talky and not terribly original, though it’s all written and drawn very well.
Grade: B+
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: – Swamp Thing in a Superman cape—best or worst thing ever?
Grade
Conclusion