The Story: Klarion drops out of school to get an early start on his career.
The Review: If there’s one area where DC definitely has Marvel beat, it’s the realm of the occult and supernatural. Magic is a crucial part of DC’s fabric, even if at times it seems like no one knows how to work with it. Klarion the Witch Boy is a good example. He has all this potential ever since Grant Morrison turned him into a blue-skinned oddball in a town of puritanical magic-users, yet you never see him around, probably because it takes a certain kind of person to write such a weirdo.
I can see Nocenti as that person. While her writing skills are often erratic and overblown, you can’t deny that no one really sounds like her, which is what a character like Klarion needs. Her voice has always had a sullen note, half-sneer, half-glower, a rebel without a cause attitude that plays right into Klarion’s dismissive regard for his spellcasting teachers and the notion of karma. He’s not a total contrarian; he has a ready “Yes, sir” when given an order on the job. He’s just the type who won’t do as he’s told unless he feels like it.
Unpredictability is Klarion‘s most distinctive feature, not always in a good way. Bleak Street is the chosen setting for the title, but it’s unclear if it’s located on Earth or some other part of the Multiverse entirely. The demon Beelzebub, who lets Klarion hitch a ride with him, implies magic should be kept on the D-L, yet magic seems to be used openly everywhere, from the ramshackle Moody Museum to the spooky Necropolitan Club. Characters and tensions are introduced with equal brevity, with Nocenti moving on to the next thing before the first one’s done.
What she really needs to do is relax and let us take in our surroundings before taking us away, because there are plenty of good ideas here, just not enough time to appreciate them. It takes half a page for Klarion to make Rasp’s acquaintance, another page to meet Zell then convince her to join his scheme, and all of a sudden we’re at a heavy metal concert where Rasp’s vendetta against the band turns towards Klarion and they’re duking it out over a hypothetical love triangle involving a girl we just met. Hard to get invested in that fight, much less the vague conflict between the Moody Museum and Necropolitan Club.
If I had been editor Harvey Richards—and I’m well aware that I am not and never will be Harvey Richards—I probably would have suggested Nocenti spent the whole issue at the Museum for us to get to know the dynamics between Rasp, Zell, proprietress Piper, and cook Noah first. By the end of the issue, they’re still largely blank slates, not even inscribed with much personality. Without strong figures to play off of, Klarion’s just a semi-likable smartass in a vacuum, with little noticeable substance.
Nocenti has one big plus going for her, however, and that’s her technical approach to magic, which is a step up from the way everyone else is writing magic these days, best described as “Anything goes.” Nocenti doesn’t exactly ground the title’s magic in rules—that’d go against the whole point of Klarion—but she gives each style of magic some basic principles which should prevent the action from devolving into senseless, arbitrary sparkles. There’s a lot of potential in breaking down Klarion’s spells to specific gestures and finger-play, or the Necropolitans’ tech-inspired brand of power.
If you’ve seen McCarthy’s work on Batwoman, you know he’s one of DC’s best-kept secrets, one of the most imaginative, ambitious stylists in their arsenal. It seems his time emulating J.H. Williams III’s stupendous paneling has stuck with him; the sequence of Beelzebub and Klarion riding a twist-tube roller coaster from a Multiversal crossway to Bleak Street is amazingly effective as both captivating visual and storytelling device. The character designs are also top-notch, both strange and strangely hip,* inspired more by urban fashion than your typical fantasy wear. Major gives a sleek finish to the pages, and dazzles once the magical effects come into play.
– Minhquan Nguyen
Grade
B
Conclusion
Conclusion: Like experimental punk rock, you have to let yourself get carried along with the sudden turns in music; commit too much to one movement and you'll easily get lost. Still, there's some good ideas and fantastic art here. Some Musings: * I especially like Zell's beehive do when she and Klarion hit the Necropolitan. Very Amy Winehouse, God rest her soul. - Are those Beats headphones around Rasp's neck? Ugh—how about saving your money and buying some cans that are actually worth it?