Some congratulations are in order as Justice League has finally caught up with the rest of the DC line at issue 35. It always seemed a little weird that the publisher’s flagship book, which made its debut ahead of every other series in the line, somehow ended up one step behind everyone else, but that all ends here. You might be asking, Why the hell does this even matter? My answer: I don’t know; I just have a feeling it does, a bit.
Maybe it’s because DC seems to be in a quiet period of renovation right now, with the renaissance among the Bat-books and several new titles coming out besides. Rather than play catch up, Justice League should be standing among the new guard as elder statesman, showing it can still move with the best of them. It can’t, really—it’s too big and ponderously conventional for that—but it can at least move in a different direction when prodded.
For Justice League, that shift manifests in a greater focus on character relationships than Johns has given before, though he mainly crutches on well-established dynamics. While he nearly exhausts the tension between Bruce glowering hostility and Luthor’s patronizing amiability, Johns gets more enjoyable results from the Trinity’s longstanding friendship. Having Diana and Clark in civilian guise at Bruce and Luthor’s partnership press event, gloating over Bruce’s superior public wooing skills, may be the one moment of genuine chemistry in the whole issue.
Unfortunately, it’s the rest of the League that needs time to bond, which Johns rarely lets them do. At best, you have one-panel moments: Jessica expressing crowd anxiety to a cheerful Barry, Vic patiently enduring Billy’s stream of tangents (“There’s a hot dog stand down the street. Can I go? It’ll only take a minute. Also, can I borrow five bucks.”). Minimal these interactions may be, but they sure beat the way Arthur just stands around alone, waiting for a chance to do something.
Plot-wise, nothing happens in the issue until the last four or five pages, when a mercenary Neutron jumps into the picture and starts wreaking havoc, all to expose the next big League threat: the Amazon Virus, whatever it is. Until that point, it’s a lot of Luthor preaching activism in his usually suspect way and expository conversation. Even the unexpected meeting of Lena Luthor doesn’t go anywhere; for the whole two or three panels in which she appears, she’s a sitting prop for Bruce and Luthor to squabble over. The tone is earnest and the dialogue mostly credible, but dull it remains.
With two A-listers like Mahnke and Reis on duty, the art can be nothing less than attractive, though this is as good an opportunity as any to note the differences in their style. Reis’ is crisp, brash, and dashing, the ideal superhero style; Mahnke is elegant, bold, slightly less perfect but the edgier for it. Neither are in the business of getting too ambitious with their storytelling (nor does Johns’ script demand it), but they deliver the story cleanly, with plenty of impact—pure function over trickery. It doesn’t matter who’s drawing, however; Anderson’s rich colors bring out the pizzazz from any visual.
Grade
B-
Conclusion
Slow, even for a Johns set-up issue. Some Musings: - "You see, those who do do and those who don't judge those who do." Believe me, Luthor, when I tell you that I have no interest in judging your do(o) do(o). - I'm with Jessica. Giving kids ice-cream after a fire is well-meaning, but mostly creepy and somewhat insensitive. I'm pretty sure if I was one of them kids, I'd be thinking, WTF is this?