While the direction of this series has already changed several times in the last year, at its core it remains a story about Loki trying to change who he was and who he might become. It’s questionable whether forcibly revising his past was the right way of going about it, but even if it worked, there’s always that damned “crime that will not be forgiven” thing hanging over his head. To say that it won’t be forgiven means that it also won’t be forgotten, which means Loki can do right for the rest of his life and still never find relief.
Painful as it may be for Loki, it may be for the best that his ultimate crime be revealed to for judgment. It’s especially important that Thor knows the truth. Despite losing his mantle and hammer, Thor (or “Odinson,” as he prefers to go by now*) is still a moral yardstick for the Asgardians. His assessment of Loki’s wrongdoing will determine their own response, which in this case turns out to be, as the vision of Kid Loki constantly warned, total condemnation.
That we feel as sorry for Loki as we do is a sign of how convincing his attempts at reformation have been. Despite his flaws, everything we’ve seen so far shows that he’s genuine about wanting to be better, and it’s rough to see that desire constantly discouraged. In fact, you’re so much on his side by this point that you might even resent Thor’s rage when Loki spills the beans. But Thor makes a strong case for his reaction, which is one of horror in addition to anger. He sees the current Loki as a child-murdering imposter, trussed in his “reborn brother’s stolen carcass!” Graphic language, but necessary because it’s true. He’s demanding that you step back and reevaluate if this crime, which from a fictional distance you were ready to let go, is truly forgivable, even with true penitence.
The circumstances that lead to Loki’s confession, however, are constructed by an Old Loki determined to guarantee his own existence. Maybe if Loki had more time to prove himself and get on better terms with Thor, his crime would go down easier—maybe. But he’s never given that chance; dispossessed of his ability to lie by a combination of the Truth Wave in Latveria and Axis and who knows what else, Loki is compelled to reveal everything to Thor when his brother is at a low moment of his own. Indeed, Thor seems suspiciously delusional when he’s pummeling Loki, repeatedly screaming that Loki’s sneering—and—and laughing—laughing and laughing—and laughing! And laughing! STOP! STOP LAUGHING!”
There’s still a touch of hope in that Thor can’t bring himself to kill Loki, remembering an earlier promise to Kid Loki to never give up on him. And Verity still tries to defend Loki, despite everything he is and has done. But things look very bleak for Loki at the moment, and you have to wonder where this is all going. Because if the end of this story is forgiveness and redemption are impossible, then that’d be freaking depressing for all involved.
One final point: while Ewing has done a fairly good job weaving his various tie-in plotlines together into something that seems almost intentional, it’s obvious that he hasn’t been in total control of this title for a while. The recap page in the middle of the issue offers the usual recitation about Loki being an agent of Asgard, but he hasn’t really been one for almost half a year. It’s also frustrating to be so dependent on other series to understand everything that’s going on here. Editor’s captions abound, telling you to read Avengers & X-Men: Axis or Angela #2 or Thor #4. Save your money; what you get in this issue is sufficient to get by, but it’s annoying for characters to constantly reference off-series events.
Garbett is usually a playful and fun sort of artist, more enthusiastic about making his characters bounce around from one gag to another, but he’s asked to do something very different for this issue. Tasked with greater emotional responsibility, he carries it out faithfully, enough to reveal the pain driving Thor’s wrath and the despair Loki’s experiencing as he keeps crying that he’s sorry, to no avail. Even Verity gets in on the drama, showing how much she cares by her dismay as she tries to intercede.
Some Musings:
* I will never call him that. Never. I don’t care what lady/gentleman/horse-mouthed alien holds the hammer, Thor is Thor and that is that.
Grade
B+
Conclusion
A surprisingly emotional issue that rightfully begs the question of whether anything Loki’s doing is worth it.