Much as I love Tomasi’s character writing, he’s not much of an ideas man. More often than not, he cobbles together just enough of a plot for his characters to stand on, and more often than not, that’s enough. But every now and then, it feels like the plot is about to collapse on itself right under the characters’ feet and Tomasi overcompensates by shoring it up with an excess of exposition. These times, it feels like he’s trying to justify what he’s already written instead of revealing what he’s planned all along.

That’s kind of what’s happening with David, a.k.a. Magog, a.k.a. WonderStar. It’s like after piling on twist after twist in regards to David’s identity, Tomasi now has this tri-part character on his hands and he has to find good reasons for all three. For David, he lays the tragedy on pretty thick, taking us to the very moment when David saw his mother brought down before his eyes. But none of that makes it any clearer why he chooses to blame Clark and Diana in particular instead of, say, the rest of the League or the Apokoliptians actually responsible for his family’s death.

As to the bizarre WonderStar persona, Circe breezily reveals, “We chose a secondary false identity simply to allow him the time to get closer to you.” The problem is we saw David’s actual transformation last issue, and at no point do you recall Circe and David having any kind of discussion about that. Also, how close could they possibly get within a few hours, which is about the length of time WonderStar existed before Magog took over. I think I preferred it when WonderStar was just this mystery occurrence; at least then you could speculate it was some subconscious manifestation of David’s heroic spirit, or some nonsense like that.

And then there’s Magog himself. Already poorly motivated and one-dimensional, he turns out to be less formidable than he first appeared, going down like a drunkard without a buddy once his staff is broken. This while Clark is multitasking on keeping the bridge from falling apart and fending off Circe’s Ani-men from the innocents in their grasp. To heap insult to injury, it’s A.R.G.U.S. who gets the last hit on Magog, remarking afterward, “Looks like he wasn’t so tough to handle after all.” Color me unimpressed.

Whichever identity turns out to be dominant, they’re all pawns for the real baddie of the arc anyway. Circe’s beef with Diana goes beyond a general hatred for men and women alike, but leaves you no less nonplussed. It’s really Hippolyta who reneged on their ancient deal, so obviously, Diana gets to reap Circe’s grudge. Diana doesn’t mince words about how ridiculous the situation is–“…I’m sick of old, forgotten myths who think the world cares about their failures.”—but beyond that, there’s not much of Tomasi’s trademark character work in the issue. Even the threat of an enchanted Clark doesn’t have much potential going for it since we just went through months of Diana going toe-to-toe with a bedeviled lover and kicking ass in the process.*

Against all this, Tomasi’s still working a different plotline in the background, one involving the characters I called cannon fodder for the last few issues. He doesn’t give us much; the mastermind is a man who holds debts over the various villains working on his behalf, and that’s about all we know. For a scene inserted smack-dab in the middle of a completely different narrative, it’s a pretty weak distraction that doesn’t get you all that excited for what’s coming next.

While there’s only so much Mahnke can do to spruce up the plot, he does maintain the A-class look of the series with his grandiose style of art. Benes does a fine job on the flashbacks, but it’s Mahnke who delivers pages worth a second look. I’m not sure this is the best comparison, but I get a real Clash of the Titans vibe from the ornate detailing he puts into the props, the raw, mythic stature and charisma of the characters. At times, you wish the inking was a little cleaner and more consistent, but unlike the story, there’s not much on the art to complain about here.

Some Musings:

* It’s called Doomed, Tomasi; didn’t you read it? Although I can’t say I blame you if you didn’t.

Grade

C+

Conclusion

There’s a lot going on here, as if Tomasi’s hoping at least something will eventually stick.