The friend of my enemy is my enemy. That’s the mirror of the common expression, but it sums up the purpose behind secret identities in the world of superheroes. If you are a warrior for truth, justice, and the American way battling against any number of nefarious villains possessed of all sorts of frightening abilities, it stands to reason that you would not want them to know your true name lest they strike at you through friends and relatives. There is some precedent for that in the real world as well, of course, in the protection given the families of high-ranking officials and the secrecy accorded witnesses in sensitive criminal cases. Of course, in the real world, even taking terrorism into account, it is statistically rare for assassins to attack friends and families of law officers or rival criminals. After all, even ruthless killers tend to have families and friends, and are thus completely vulnerable to retaliation in kind.
In Superman #44, Gene Luen Yang provides a rare exploration of the true function of secret identities in the society of the DC Universe. As the issue opens, Clark Kent has been exposed as Superman. Lois Lane, in an attempt to save him from blackmail, and indeed from torture, broadcast the truth of his identity across social media. As Clark is literally walking down the street minding his own business, he runs afoul of the current incarnation of the Royal Flush Gang, bent on revenge for their defeats at the hands of the man if steel and determined to take advantage of his depowered state to obtain satisfaction. Unfortunately for them, even a weakened Superman is more than capable of defending himself against such a threat.
Clark proceeds to the Daily Planet, which is rapidly besieged by a further series of vengeful foes, luckily none on the truly dangerous level of a Braniac or a Lex Luthor. However, the battles against these threats aren’t the important developments. The truly critical plot beats come as Clark’s life and relationships rapidly unravel. Yang has realised something that most writers overlook or ignore: a secret identity is, after all, a profound and systematic web of lies told not only to your enemies, not only to the public, but to allies and friends and even family. When that kind of lie breaks down, the backlash of blame and anger washes everything before it. One of those attacking Clark is a former Planet employee whose wife was killed by a supervillain long before Clark’s identity was revealed. He believes that his association with Superman, even unwittingly, was the ruination of his life. It isn’t true, his wife’s death was a random occurrence, but such is the kind of reasoning that happens when great lies are exposed. This all finds a perfect symbol in an angry, wounded Perry White slapping the just-fired Clark, knocking away his glasses, the iconic representation of superhero secret identities for more than seventy-five years.
Grade
Conclusion
The book ends with the villain, HORDR_ROOT revealing that he is the child of an old enemy of Superman's. Which? I haven't a clue, to be honest. But the revelation serves to seal the theme of lies and secrets that threads through the entire issue. Yang has struggled throughout this arc to make a strong and coherent statement of his themes. Last issue he at last managed to do so. With this issue he follows through. It is not enough to recover completely from a weak beginning, but it is enough to keep the story solidly anchored and moving forward. The only sour note to many will be Clark's reaction to the threat against his loved ones. It is perfectly natural, and perfectly logical. Let us just say that he realizes fictional killers, like real ones, are vulnerable to retaliation. Many people would not find that in keeping with the ethos of Superman, logical or not. But that is a matter for another issue.