By: Robert (writer), Charlie Adlard (pencils), Stefano Gaudiano (inks), Cliff Rathburn (gray tones) and Rus Wooton (letters)
The Story: Is Rick dying or not?
Review (with SPOILERS): I hada lot of “mixed feelings” with this issue. It’s honestly been a difficult one to even review. It’s just not an issue that inspires a single, unified feeling, just lots of stray thoughts and disappointments. And that’s a fail for this issue. The action is coming to a crescendo, and it should inspire a solid feeling rather than a bunch of stray thoughts.
Teasing death is cheap: This cliffhanger would be a million times more effective if Kirkman hadn’t just yanked the football from in front of us a few issues ago. I mean, we just saw this BIG tease that Rick was going to die because of the zombie-goop bolt. That turned out to be a total nothing, so why should we get excited that Rick has nicked Negan’s neck with a knife? Charlie Adlard could have drawn that scene any way he wanted to (or any way Kirkman asked him to). It looks like a nick for a reason. If they wanted to kill Negan, that knife would be buried up to the hilt. They could have used either of these implied death cliffhangers, but not both.
Too much talking!: My goodness did Rick go on and on before trying to stab Negan! They were building a better place, they were working together, blah, blah… It’s the same rhetoric we heard back at the Prison and countless times in Alexandria. I get it and it’s a noble goal. It’s what we would all strive for in the apocalypse, but farming and blacksmithing don’t make for a very compelling story. I know that Rick was talking about that to distract Negan so he could stab him, but he could have talked about anything. He could have talked about surrendering. He could have talked smack. But, instead he talked about a theme that has already been kinda played out from a storytelling standpoint. We’ve seen TWD do a “Let’s re-establish society!” theme for 40+ issues. It’s time to see something else.
Negan is great: I really hope Negan isn’t dying because he’s so much fun. Honestly, when he started agreeing with Rick’s spiel, I thought he was just going along with it to pull Rick’s leg, and the next second he was going to say, “What? Are you nuts? Just listen to yourself, Rick? You sound insane!”I thought we were going to see him try to whack Rick with Lucille. Negan is such an outstanding character, so well-written and drawn, that thinking Negan was about to play his own little trick on Rick is a perfectly plausible explanation. It’s a credit to the creators that we can even speculate about such things. Comics are usually pretty literal, but Negan allows for subtext.
So, where does all this leave us? I’m afraid I can’t look forward to any of the major storytelling possibilities. If either Rick or Negan dies next issue, I’ll feel like this story was too long. It isn’t that we didn’t need the All Out War story, but twelve issues and making artistic compromises to achieve bi-weekly shipping probably wasn’t necessary. On the other hand, if both of these guys walk away unscathed next issue, it will feel cheap that they’ve both had their deaths teased, keeping the story from moving forward. What would be next? All Out War II?