By Geoff Johns (writer), Brett Booth (artist), Andrew Dalhouse (colors), Nick J. Napolitano (letters)

The Story: Larfleeze comes to Earth looking for that almighty, endless source of material wish fulfillment, Santa Claus. Of course, our favorite avatar of avarice is extremely perturbed when his offering of milk and cookies go unanswered, and Hal Jordan is forced to intervene before Larfleeze melts the entire North Pile in his desperate attempt to locate the jolly old elf.

What’s Good: I really appreciate Johns’ overall approach to Larfleeze’s take on Santa as well; on hearing the premise, I assumed that Larfleeze would set out to try and kidnap Santa, or at least steal his bag of gifts. The fact that he interprets Santa as a gift giving entity, and actually follows our Christmas traditions in an attempt to summon him, is unexpectedly endearing. So much so, in fact, that I rather sympathized with his attack on the North Pole. Santa is a difficult enough concept for Earth kids to work through; it must be that much more difficult for an avarice fueled alien from another galaxy.

One thing I really did like, the comic itself aside, were the extras thrown in: a recipe for orange holiday cookies (I actually waited to write this review until I had a chance to bake them–I can safely say they’re worth the time if you like orange flavor and are cookie-inclined), a maze game and a cut-out Christmas ornament (thoughtfully placed on the back of an ad, fortunately.) Not, I think, that you actually have to bake the cookies or cut out the ornament to enjoy them; just having them as a part of the book is a nice touch, and actually adds quite a bit to its holiday ambiance.

What’s Not So Good: Although Larfleeze’s assumptions about Santa are unique and interesting, nothing else about he issue really stands out as unexpected. Once you understand the premise, it plays out pretty much like you’d expect. One thing I didn’t expect was such a sad ending to a Christmas story! I know Larfleeze’s whole deal is avarice, and that he can’t very well pull an Ebenezer Scrooge and change his ways…but man, leaving him alone like that at the end is pretty harsh. A Christmas Special isn’t the place to make a point about the futility of materialism! After all of Hal’s speechifying, it would have been nice to see Larfleeze have some kind of a happy ending somehow, even if it was just a momentary appreciation of the horde of things he’s already been able to accumulate. Or something–anything but leaving him alone and missing his family on Christmas!

conclusion: A light, fluffy romp with one of DC’s best new characters. However, four bucks is extremely steep for a book like this. I can’t recommend it at cover price unless you really, truly love the character. Otherwise, waiting for a sale or bargain bin is definitely the way to go.

Grade: C

-SoldierHawk

 

Grade

Conclusion