By Jimmy Palmiotti & Justin Gray (writers), Travis Moore (penciller), Trevor Scott (inker), Rob Schwager (colorist)

The Story: The Fighters discover metahuman convict escapees are tougher to deal with than they think, and the rumors regarding mutant creatures in sewer bottoms may have some credit.

The Review: The nonstop action continues as Jimmy Palmiotti and Justin Gray gleefully toss the Freedom Fighters from one scene of chaos to another.  This time, however, the onslaught of narrative-hopping subsides as the masterminds behind the prison break are revealed.  In doing so, Palmiotti and Gray are slowly gelling together the various plotlines they’ve strung through past issues.

Palmiotti-Gray still run into problems with pacing.  Before, the story went all over the place at breakneck speed, never allowing any one scene to play itself out before leaping to the next.  This issue has the reverse problem; it drags its heels in one place for way too long and gets only a couple choice tidbits of new information out of it.  Sure, since it’s Palmiotti-Gray, there’ll probably be some huge payoff at the end of the road.  But in the meantime, it’s vital they offer some progress, either in developing the characters or giving some substance to the plot.

Sadly, even after all the troubles they’ve faced together, the personalities and dynamics among the Fighters still remain a big fat blank.  You really don’t know anything about who these heroes are beneath the costumes and political rhetoric.  Their dialogue mostly consists of the usual groaners of battle-quips or clichés (“All I see is a tough guy who likes to kick women,” and “It doesn’t have to work like this,” being prime examples—all in one panel).  None of these lines do much to give each character a distinctive personality; taken together, they all sound pretty much the same.

The characterization and dialogue of the Jailbreakers, the Fighters’ opponents, aren’t much better.  At least each Jailbreaker has a semi-specific kind of crazy to their talk.  But most of the time they keep rambling on and on about the injustice of being locked away for apparently no reason and experimented on with science and magic—well, alright, that is a pretty good subject to harp on.  But imagine them repeating the same talking points, panel after panel, page after page, either standing around or even in the midst of battle, for most of the issue.

If there’s one thing preventing Palmiotti-Gray from becoming ingenious writers on top of being star ones, it’s their over-reliance on talkiness to get anything done.  The Jailbreakers got some big talk about what they suffered, but you never see it, so it’s hard to take them seriously.  They just read like the usual vengeful lunatics to me, and we’ve already got enough of those in this story arc.  Events never speak for themselves in this series; someone’s always got to flap his mouth about it.

And it’s not as if the art isn’t perfectly capable of showing what’s happening.  Travis Moore still provides really detailed lines and designs, and there’s really very little he can’t draw well (the splash of Black Condor in the face of some monstrous creepy-crawlies looks especially great).  Moore’s talents seem restricted by a lack of dynamism in the story itself, but make no mistake: if Palmiotti-Gray take some care in setting up their scenes a little more creatively, Moore will probably fly higher than he already does.

Conclusion: At least one loose end gets tied up in this issue, but there are still a lot of dangling threads left to cover.  Strong art livens up an otherwise roundabout story that gives the Fighters some good challenges to get over, but doesn’t actually take the plot anywhere.

Grade: B-

-MQ Nguyen

Some Musings: – The warden, in the throes of his own self-inflicted death, explains to his escaped prisoners in his last moments: “Poison tooth…the prison’s…safety protocol omega…when my artificial heart stops…the countdown…” I’m surprised he didn’t throw in a “My real name is Dick Whitman!” as a final flourish.

– And the award for Least Helpful Description of a Magical Artifact goes to: “Different from the Rock of Eternity, but similar.”  Yeahbutwhu–?

– Okay, seriously—the demon with a hundred babies attached to him?  Kudos to Palmiotti-Gray for coming up with such a disturbing concept, but they’re really testing my stomach for twisted visuals here.

 

Grade

Conclusion