By: Brian K. Vaughan (writer), Fiona Staples (artist)

The Story: Well, an episode of How I Met Your Mother this ain’t.

The Review: Alex already made some excellent points about this issue, so I won’t go around stepping on his toes, but I do want to make a few observations of my own about this series that’s already received so much attention.  Obviously, a title like Saga comes attached with some pretty high expectations.  It means Vaughan must not only deliver a complex narrative with adequately vast scope, he must have enough material of sufficient depth and quality to do so.

In other words, you don’t make Star Wars by playing it safe, story-wise.  So it’s a pretty good sign that right off the bat, Vaughan throws in every sci-fi/fantasy feature you can think of into the series: opposing races, winged humanoids and bestial humanoids, robot third-parties, hulking creatures of implausible shape and anatomy, advanced technology and old-school magic, guns and swords—you name it, this issue has it.

Above all else, Vaughan gives us the very best kind of story of all: a love story, set between two members of opposing races fighting a fruitless war that’s been corrupted and prolonged beyond recognition.  This is classic stuff—and that is perhaps the one and only flaw with the tale Vaughan wants to tell here.  We can all recognize this story, and we can all sense its general direction, especially since a vital character reveals from the start a large chunk of the end game.

But again, even the oldest story in the world can be made like new by its execution, and Vaughan executes masterfully.  Despite the exotic, breathlessly imaginative world we’re dealing with, we recognize it because Vaughan starts us, appropriately enough, with the most fundamental, universal, human experience of all: the birth of a child of love.  That alone is not enough, however.  To immerse you into the scene, Vaughan does not spare you even from its less attractive parts (“It feels like I’m shitting!” mother Alana cries; father Marko cuts off the umbilical cord—with his teeth).

So yes, you enter the series with both feet on the ground, decidedly caught in the tale.  What keeps you in until the end is the deep connection between Marko and Alana, one we empathize with because even though the context of their conversation is often strange and foreign to us (“Wing-bleeding isn’t religious, it’s…cultural,” Alana insists), their attitudes and feelings are very familiar (“What is cultural about mutilating an infant?” Marko demands.  Alana replies, “Are we really having a fight now?  Because that’s how we ended up making this one.”).

I’m ashamed to say I’ve never had any experience with Staples’ work before, but I certainly plan to keep my eye on her career from now on.  She immediately sets herself apart from the breadth of artists out there by using a very potent combination of painted backgrounds and boldly sketched figures.  The effect is to create something that is at once dynamic and powerful, yet also delicate and giving, like a Miyazaki animated movie put to paper.  The colors are breathtaking as well, bright and vivid in the foreground, deep and rich in the back.  The best compliment I can give Staples is she manages to make a bleeding, mutated infant look like something worth crying tears of joy over.  Is that enough?

Conclusion: Beautifully told and beautifully rendered, a smash of a first issue, although perhaps a tad predictable in its initial construction.  Most likely, though, this will evolve into quite something, don’t you think?

Grade: B+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Alana, I’m behind you one-hundred percent on, “If you think I’m calling my daughter [Hope], I want a divorce.”

– Did anyone see the antlered “chaplain” and think that it was Sweet Tooth’s Gus gone Obi-Wan Kenobi style?

Grade

Conclusion