
The Story: Curb-stomping your way to better relations with the neighbors.
The Review (SPOILER ALERT):
1. Andrea’s time is up. – She needs to die, right? It isn’t just that the character is unlikeable, but there’s really nothing left to do with Andrea. She ended her relationship with Michonne over a desperate hope for safety and a normal life. She stayed loyal to the Governor after seeing his zombie games and zombie daughter and his zombie head collection. Then, after putting on her big-girl pants and heading off to the prison, she learns the truth. The Governor (her boyfriend) had started a fight, killed people and lied to her about it. She returns to the Governor with a plan for a little post-coital throat-slashing, but after everything she found out, she still can’t do it. There’s really nothing left for the writers to do with Andrea. She’s just a loser and will be remembered more as the woman who tried to blow herself up at the CDC, and the lady whining about “her gun” and the lady who chose a few more nights in a warm bed over killing the villain. It’s a shame. There were glimmers of hope for the character here and there over the three seasons, but I don’t see how they redeem her now. I guess they could make her a full-on villain, but she’s too much of a wuss to be a good villain.
2. Enjoying Merle’s new situation. – Merle just makes everything better. Having good actors is important, and Michael Rooker is a quality actor. Put him in a scene with Michonne and suddenly she isn’t quite so wooden. Or compare the impact of the Merle and Herschel Bible-chat to Rick and Carl talking about Rick’s future as group leader–no contest. Merle is an interesting character and I look forward to learning more about him. He probably has the ability to rise above the tepid writing on this show.
3. Why does everyone trust Milton? – First we saw the Governor asking Milton to keep an eye on Andrea last week. Now we see Andrea asking Milton to “cover for her” while she goes on a scouting mission to the prison. Besides the question of how Milton is covering for her, we have to wonder why everyone trusts Milton so much? The whole thing feels like an effort to justify the Milton character who really has nothing useful to do.
4. Tyrese switch-a-roo. – Now HERE is a clever idea and a big deviation from the comics. I love this sort of stuff. You can clearly see where this is headed. Tyrese will tell the Governor about the back entrance to the Prison and instead of the raid coming from outside the fence, Rick & Co. will get attacked from the rear. It’s also interesting to see Tyrese being turned into the unwitting tool of Rick’s demise, although I hope Tyrese has a better story arc than the traitorous hunchback in 300. I’m very curious to see where this will go.
5. Carl & Glen = Blah. – The Peter Principal really applies to Glen in this episode. This leadership role really doesn’t suit him and it isn’t believable at all. And while they’re writing all these awkward scenes of Glen’s leadership, they’re neglecting the Glen/Maggie relationship (which symbolize hope) that is very important to the show. Meanwhile, someone in the writing crew thought that Carl was the best messenger to tell Rick that he wasn’t in charge anymore. Carl is older enough to come along on raids now, but even in the zombie apocalypse, nobody wants to hear leadership opinions from a 12 year old.
6. American History Z – Well, that curb-stomp on the zombie was pretty gross, huh? Even though it didn’t really have much to do with “the plot” of the episode, the whole scene where Milton and Andrea wrangle the zombie, amputate its arms and curb-stomp out its teeth was pretty snappy. I enjoy the really sharp make-up effects in an era when almost everything is CGI.
7. Musical numbers – Did someone watch Beth leading a sing-along earlier in the series and say, “That was AWESOME! We need to do THAT again!” I love how none of the other characters joins in. And the whole thing where they play some song in as the fade to the credits is very ballsy. The only shows that I’ve seen do this effectively are much, much better shows than TWD.
Conclusion: An okay episode that metaphorically finished off an annoying character. I guess that’s progress? Even with all the sing-along lameness, I am excited that we can see the basic shape of the big finale.
Grade: B
– Dean Stell
Grade
Conclusion