WALKING DEAD S03E13

The Story: The big meeting we’ve all been waiting for: Rick & The Governor.

Things We Liked and Disliked About This Episode:

1. The two-hander episode – The structure of this episode was really odd. Almost every scene was a two-hander.  We had Rick/Governor, Milton/Herschel, Daryl/Martinez, Maggie/Glen, Herschel/Andrea, Rick/Herschel, etc.  Herschel was kinda busy.  It was almost like a series of auditions where they kept mixing characters together to find combinations that worked well together.  Some of the combos were really weak; like the Rick/Governor scenes, but some were compelling, which made the episode a little more interesting.  Mostly, I applaud the shows creators for mixing up the formula of the show even if it wasn’t wholly successful.

2. Interesting dilemma for Rick – I like the challenge that the Governor has tossed out to Rick: Give us Michonne and all will be forgiven.  Coming on the heels of last week’s episode where Rick and Carl bonded with Michonne, it actually shows that the creators have some grasp of a dramatic arc.  Granted, it is a fumbling arc as Rick went from irrationally hating Michonne to really liking her a lot in one episode, but that’s about all we can expect from this show.  Hey, we’ll take character arcs however they come in this show.

Let’s see how the show handles this dilemma…  It could go very badly.  The solution is very simple. You sacrifice Michonne for the greater good.  Hopefully, there is no hand-wringing about how doing so would mean, “sacrificing our humanity” or any such crap.  I have a feeling that all the people who worry about “lost humanity” wouldn’t survive the first month of the apocalypse.  Do something useful with the dilemma. Put Michonne in break-away handcuffs like Chewbacca in Star Wars and spring a trap on the Governor, put a bag over her head and dress her in long sleeves and gloves and have it be Carol under the hood to show Andrea how to properly slash a throat, etc.

3. Chained heat! – Two hot things happened at the Prison this week.  For one thing, Merle is not okay with this sitting around crap while “his brother is out there.”  I like how Merle adds a random element to the group.  If not for Merle, it would just be Beth trying to get the others to play sing-along with her.  The other hot thing was Maggie & Glen.  Glen is so fish-out-of-water when he tries to be Rick’s lieutenant, but he works really well as Maggie’s boyfriend.  It was nice to see Maggie snapping out of her post-Woodbury experience.  Did that 4-5 week period of moping around the Prison accomplish anything?

4. Great cinematography – There was the one moment at the end of the episode where we saw Rick’s group and the Governor’s group driving away from the meeting place and the scene was shot from straight above.  It was a clever scene to show them going their separate ways.  But, if you look at the scene again, you’ll notice that when the cars pull away, they kinda form a yin-and-yang symbol with the way they swerved around each other.  That was very cool.  And there were a number of other clever elements such as two characters arguing and the way they framed the scene with a fence post between the characters.  That was nifty.  Or all those above scenes of Rick & the Governor in the shack where they show them through the hole in the roof to emphasize that they’re locked in there together.  Again, very clever.  The behind camera talent in TWD is very, very good.

5. Dull and too many flaws to be really great – How do you grade an episode where everything is quite good except for the central story starring the main characters?  That is my grading dilemma.  I imagine the other actors peeking into the Rick/Gov hut and cringing as Andrew Lincoln and David Morrissey make a hash of things.  The sports analog would be like watching Dwight Howard brick his free throws.  Rick looked like he had somewhere else to be the whole time– like he drank a LOT of coffee and had to take a piss.  The Governor looked like he wanted nothing more than for this season of wearing the eyepatch to end so he could go back to doing theatre in England.  This was anything but Al Pachino and Robert DeNiro in Heat.  The thing that makes the scene worse is that the creators play it up like it is a BIG deal.  Play it lower key and it won’t feel like such a dud. Play it a lower key and the other elements of the show can carry the episode.

Conclusion: This episode was like a cheap chocolate Easter bunny. It was yummy-looking on the outside and tasty to lick, but ultimately unsatisfying because it is hollow and crumbles when you bite into it.  The Governor will be gone and dead before long, but Rick will be an enduring problem for this show.

Grade: B-

-Dean Stell

Grade

Conclusion