
The Story: The Governor is a dirty, back-stabbing bastard.
The Review (SPOILER ALERT):
1. Tight, horror-themed episode – This was a very good episode. The real stars of this show are mostly behind the camera and in the editing suites. That Andrea/Governor cat-and-mouse in the old factory was really HOT and most of the hotness stems from lighting, camera-work, editing, music, etc… It really makes me wonder why this show doesn’t do THAT all the time. It’s like a baseball pitcher who has 100 mph fastball, but is constantly dicking around with mediocre curve balls. Just throw the fastball over and over and over until it stops working.
An interesting observation about the old factory scene was how much better it was than earlier scenes of Andrea doing her 5K. Zombies outside aren’t very scary because you have to construct weird circumstances for the zombies to have a chance (like stopping to rest against a double-trunked tree so a zombie can sneak up and hold you in place for the other zombies). Zombies in dark places where you don’t have room to maneuver and don’t know where you are going are really scary. It gets a lot worse when you’re being stalked through a dark place by a creepy psychotic ex-boyfriend with a shovel and a whistling habit. That whole scene was tense and came out very well. It kinda reminded me of those late-80s/early-90s thrillers like Deceived or Malice or Blue Steel.
But, even though the big set-piece was the star of the episode, it wasn’t the only good horror moment. Did anyone anticipate the Governor nabbing Andrea right at the threshold of the Prison? She was THIS close and then bam! That particular surprise was made more effective because it wasn’t telegraphed in advance. If you pay attention, the episode had previously telegraphed several other Andrea surprises such as the tree zombie and a few others in the factory, but they took away the telegraphing camera movement for the big surprise. They didn’t want us to see that one coming. Good for them.
There was even a very cool Silence of the Lambs-esque scene at the very end: out-of-context, insanity rock music and first-person zooming camera through the crazy man’s lair to the trapped woman. Cool.
I wish TWD would just surrender to being a horror show. I know, I know, “there is so much MORE to the comics,” but this show usually stumbles badly when it tries to do anything else. Would it really be so bad to be a great horror-themed TV show?
2. Less Rick or just less distraction? – A few weeks ago we had that excellent bottle episode with Rick, Michonne and Carl meeting Crazy Morgan. That episode excelled because of its reduced scope. THIS episode shows what can happen when you reduce the scope of the show AND exile Rick & Co. from the proceedings. Honestly, I’d bet that nobody wants to see that crap at the awful Prison— Glen yelling, Rick scowling, Beth singing…
3. Who burned up the zombies? – It had to be Milton, right? Maybe it was some other random Woodbury townie who has had ENOUGH, but I’m pretty sure it was Milton. I’m just curious to see what character arc creators have lined up for him. Like Merle and Darryl, Milton is a new character who doesn’t come from the comics, so I have no way of predicting what will become of him. Will he make some heroic sacrifice and kill the Governor? Will he be the new leader? Even though Milton is quiet, he doesn’t seem totally benign for some reason.
4. Tyrese given something to do – It wasn’t “awesome” and – frankly – it’s basically Chad Coleman playing the exact same character he played on “The Wire,” but it was nice to see Tyrese figuring into the plot. It still feels a little tacked on and “extra,” but I’m sure Tyrese will have a bigger role to play before the finale.
5. Even Governor and Andrea were good! – It’s a testament to this episode’s quality that they made such an enjoyable episode featuring two of the most annoying characters on the show. Having the Governor prowling around an old factory with a shovel was genuinely haunting. I totally believe that he is a sicko killer. Similarly, Andrea couldn’t be more annoying when she’s trying to broker peace or whining about her gun. But having her running and hiding was magical. It’s almost too bad we didn’t find out if Andrea could do a B-movie scream.
6. Foreshadowing? – Is there any doubt that Michonne is going to save Andrea from the world’s most awful dentist’s chair? As a side-note, why does the Governor have a speculum among his stainless steel horror tools? Usually the visual shorthand for “torture implements” is “lots of pliers and a few scalpels;” sometimes they toss in a blowtorch. A speculum? Did one of his henchmen put that in there as a practical joke? Is he planning to do a cervical exam? Doesn’t he have the wrong kind of torture chair for that? Does the Governor know what he’s doing with this torture stuff? Anyway, with that flashback to Andrea and Michonne “on the road,” it’s clear that these two women will be reunited.
7. A few things still hold it back… – Even with all the good things in this episode, there are still a few things that hold it back from the highest marks. If you want to get “A” grades on my scale, you have to be perfect and not leave the most basic questions unanswered. Firstoff, where are all the Woodbury townies? Do they hide indoors? And why is the Governor’s monster truck so loud? Why is Tyrese shooting left handed? Doing so with a right-handed gun is a good way to break your nose on the bolt-action. If Tyrese can’t shoot very well, why not just have him use the rifle in the way it’s designed to be used? How did The Governor get Andrea back to Woodbury? I point these things out not to imply that it was a bad episode, but the BEST episodes on TV don’t have this many loose threads.
Conclusion: A very strong episode that shows TWD works best when it plays the horror card.
Grade: A-
– Dean Stell
Grade
Conclusion