By: Far too many to list, of course. IMDB it.
The Story: The USS Enterprise considers starting a tab a the repair shop.
The Review: Hold on to your keyboards, because I’m about to make a pretty big confession, a shocking one in our proudly geeky world. I like Star Trek better than Star Wars. There—I said it. Mind you, I’m not saying that one is better than the other. For whatever reason, I just resonate more with the spirit of Star Trek and the values it embraces. Corny as this sounds, I love that it tries to give us a vision of humanity at our very best, of a brighter future ahead.
The last movie, delightful and entertaining as it was, didn’t quite capture that spirit. Instead, it went for balls-to-the-wall action, fueled by youthful energy, warm humor, and deeply touching emotions. It was a great film in its way, opening the franchise to a wider audience than any Trek film could previously imagine, but in the process it minimized the higher calling and mission of the series. The critical question for its sequel, then, is whether it will continue to capitalize on the spectacle that renewed its reputation or will it return to the principles that made the original premise culturally relevant.
Into Darkness charts itself on a credible middle ground between the two courses. All the flashes and bangs are still here; the movie is chock-full of them, throwing one dire complication after another, making it seem ever more improbable the crew of the USS Enterprise can survive to a complete trilogy. But in the quiet pauses between crises, the movie does question its ideological integrity. Granted, the moral territory the film wanders through is not as gray as it would like you to believe. Neither of its major villains has much in the way of sympathy or nobility, and as a result, they are rather one-dimensional, if formidable, antagonists.
However, their actions do force our characters, especially Kirk, to reaffirm the values of the institution they serve: justice without vengeance, strict order tempered by compassion, peace in the face of invitations to war. The film thus ends not by satiating our thirst for blood, but on an appeal to our ever-hungry curiosity; to explore rather than execute.
Ultimately, our heroes navigate their moral quandaries with their compasses still intact and their spirit none the worse for wear. In fact, the lead characters sustain disappointingly little long-term damage from the experience. Ships get rebuilt, relationships repaired, and—spoiler alert—lives resurrected. Even so, our characters do come away from the film wiser, less reckless and more thoughtful than when they began.
For no one is that more true than Kirk and Spock, dually the heart and soul of Star Trek. At the start of the film, it’s clear that although their opposing personalities no longer clash as violently as they once did, there remains a gap in their different outlooks on life which continues to breed tension and even sadness between them. This gap narrows over the course of the story until, at the end, they exchange roles, each embracing the beliefs and instincts the other holds dear. I’m rather delighted that in a film that could have pushed two romantic subplots on us, the real love story ends up being Spock and Kirk. More than just counselors, they become each other’s source of comfort in pain, thereby delivering the most heartrending moments of the film.*
While our two leads do get the most time in the spotlight, the film remains largely an ensemble effort. Everyone gets a chance to shine, though perhaps with less humor and impact as in their last appearances. Uhura, Sulu, Chekov, Scotty, and McCoy all get substantial parts in the plot, it’s true, but for several of them, their contributions don’t do much to sway the course of the film one way or another. At the same time, the other members of the Enterprise get a little more prominence, and collectively, they reinforce the idea that these ships live and die by the strength of their teamwork. By the end of the film, these nameless individuals are almost as recognizable and essential to the story as the main cast.*
Conclusion: The first film in the Star Trek reboot had all the potential to be a one-hit wonder, but its sequel proves almost as dazzlingly entertaining and more emotionally sincere than ever.
Grade: B
– Minhquan Nguyen
Some Musings: * I admit that I’m kind of an emotional softy, but I assure you that there were plenty of audible sniffs and quavery breaths in the audience besides me at the big emotional moments.
* I was especially taken with the big-boned, bald black woman who provided support on the bridge. We get a couple aliens in the mix, too.
Grade
Conclusion