FATALE #16

By: Ed Brubaker (story), Sean Phillips (art), Elizabeth Breitweiser (colors)

The Story: Jo proves that being a groupie and a muse are not mutually exclusive roles.

The Review: “Magical realism” was a term we threw around a lot back in my creative writing days.  It seemed a fancy concept back then, but now I think it was just people’s way of getting shoehorned into certain genres: fantasy, sci-fi, horror, occult, etc.  At any rate, the phrase is a useful way of describing the most convincing supernatural elements, the kind that feel as though they can exist, barely perceptible, in the real world.

The most impressive quality of Brubaker’s craft is the how, even though he’s made it clear that a very real mysticism is at work in this series, he grounds it so well in the ordinary world that you don’t always know when you’re seeing magic or simply the spectacle of human behavior and psychology gone wrong.  This is the wellspring of one of Fatale’s most compelling questions: whether Jo’s allure comes from her unusual nature, or whether it’s simply the byproduct of being a charming, sensitive, utterly beautiful woman.

Here, you can see how this question inevitably arises with each and every interaction she has with a man.  There’s really nothing extraordinary about her gestures or exchanges: the kindness she shows to a Wulf as a boy, her good humor (she takes on the soubriquet of Jane Doe during her bout of amnesia) and love of music around Lance, or her quiet compassion towards tortured artist Tom.  You can’t pick out any one mannerism or line which stands out as overtly unnatural.

Yet you can’t overlook the extremities in these men’s reactions to her.  Take Wulf’s lifelong obsession with recreating the “purity” of the moment from his childhood where she, a complete stranger, wiped the blood from his nose after a fight with his brother.  There’s no indication of psychotic behavior prior to this scene, but there’s no other way to describe his terrible acts afterwards besides psychotic.  It’s hard to believe, under these circumstances, that Jo didn’t inspire this madness in him—at least not without learning a few more details about Wulf’s life.

The fact that prior to her accident Jo would caution against a man getting too deeply involved with her indicates that whatever strange power she has, it invariably turns out grim in the end.  Without the memories of her experiences to guide her, she’s now letting her attraction run unchecked, feeding into the already tumultuous clash of personalities within the Amsterdam household.  No member of the band, even its sole woman, is left unaffected by Jo’s presence, and as each is brought closer to the brink of their emotions, you’re left dreading yet simultaneously anticipating the breakdown to come.

I continue to struggle with Fatale as a latecomer to the title.  Without a recap page or much in the way of context, it’s almost impossible to figure out how Gavin’s search for Jo ties into the Amsterdam and Wulf plotlines.  This is undoubtedly part of an overarching story that Brubaker’s been telling, but for anyone who hasn’t been following it all along, they’ll be left hopelessly confused at the end of the issue.

There’s a certain bluntness to Phillips’ art which parallels the raw emotions on display in the script.  His figures have almost no elegance or grace whatsoever, but they seem all the more human for it, in the same manner as when the Impressionists de-emphasized line and yet were able to render a more true-to-life image as a result.  Whether this is a kind of commentary or not, it’s interesting that the male characters tend to be splotched with shadowy patches, while the women remain unobscured.  Perhaps this is Phillips’ artistic way of showing how Jo’s powers bring out the dark parts of men’s souls.

Conclusion: Even with a minimum of activity, Brubaker generates more suspense in an issue than most writers do in five.  Along with tasteful artistic support from Phillips, this is the more inexplicably gripping series out there, even if a bit baffling at times.

Grade: B+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – If Scott Walker as a solo act is Tom’s big inspiration, then he really does have artistic problems.

Grade

Conclusion