
Main story by: Scott Snyder (writer), Greg Capullo (pencils), Danny Miki (inks), FCO Plascencia (colors) and Nick Napolitano (letters)
Back-up story by: Snyder & James Tynion, IV (writers), Rafael Albuquerque (art), Dave McCaig (colors), Dezi Sienty (letters)
The Story: Attacked in his own home, young Bruce Wayne is inspired to “become the bat.”
The Review: This is a tricky comic to review because I’m starting to feel that this Zero Year storyline is written for people who are not me. As I consume this story (issue by issue), I cannot help trying to shoehorn its events into Bat-continuity. I literally spend the whole time thinking, “Is this at the same time as Year One? Is it before? After? Gosh, it seems like the same time as Year One, but how could this happen when we already know that that happened?” Of course by Year One, I’m referring to the classic 1987 four-issue storyline by Frank Miller and David Mazzucchelli. That story is about as perfect as any superhero story that has ever been written: tight, focused, well paced, poignant and beautifully illustrated. I’ve reread Year One a few times over the years, and while many 1980’s superhero stories don’t “hold up” (see: Dark Phoenix Saga or the Kree-Skrull War), Year One still has its mojo. But, this isn’t specifically a problem with comparing Zero Year with Year One. It happens to me anytime superhero comics gaze backwards because I’m a person who tries to complete the puzzle, and often superhero comics make me feel as if they are multiple puzzles combined that have the same finished picture, but where the pieces have been cut differently so that you can’t mix-and-match; you can get a general outline of what the characters look like, but never a tidy image.
On the other hand, even though Year One is great, it is also close to 30 years old. Sometimes you gotta freshen up your look and I don’t want to be the old dude who holds back progress by demanding that all comics of today conform to the comics I read 30+ years ago. New 52 and all that… It’s just that maybe these comics aren’t for me, or at least I realize they aren’t quite for me when they look backward. I find I like the “continuing saga” but not the history anymore.
Anyway, putting all the personal mewling to the side, this is a pretty solid comic book. Just put aside your continuity baggage and enjoy it. If I were 20 instead of almost 40, this would probably be the most incredible thing I’d ever read. Scott Snyder is continuing to paint a nifty picture of young Bruce Wayne, all full of juice and ready to “fight crime…” Except he doesn’t really know what that means yet. And it results in the Red Hood gang attacking him in his own home and leaving him for dead. It’s the kind of moment when Bruce realizes he either needs to step up a LOT or just give up. Since he is Bruce Wayne, you know he’s going to step up, but this issue really illustrated that hooded vigilantism is no time for half-measures (except for the whole non-lethal force thing, but that’s Batman for you). For the first time in this issue, I found myself to be really compelled by the Red Hood and started to wonder, “Who IS this guy?” That’s a good sign because I really didn’t give a damn about him for his first few appearances. Now I’m very curious. I’ve heard a few people speculate that it could be The Joker, but I can’t imagine it being anything that banal. The overall story is chugging along as we watch Bruce Wayne morph from a rich guy who wants to do well into The Batman.
Two parts of this issue didn’t really click with me. One is all the Riddler stuff. I’ve seen a lot of people fanboying over how cool it is to see a young Riddler who already has many of the mannerisms of adult Riddler. I just don’t see how that is clever. I mean, this isn’t like watching an old home movie of your grandfather and seeing that he packed his pipe the same way in 1940 as he does today because Riddler isn’t a real person. We know what happens with this guy and so do the creators and editors. This isn’t really a story that takes place in the past, it happens in 2013. They only tell you it happened in the past. So, it’s pretty easy to sprinkle a few mannerisms on The Riddler.
The other part that I just didn’t get was all the time-bouncing between Bruce in the “present” and Bruce as a child who had fallen down the well. It just seemed choppy and didn’t serve a lot of purpose. Then later when Bruce activates that hologram projector and sees the cave again, I really didn’t understand what was going on. I feel like there is some connection between Bruce’s Dad and Batman that I’m supposed to gather here, but it eludes me. Maybe I would have loved the issue more if that part had made more sense to me?
Artwise, Batman continues to be a tour de force. There is a HUGE amount of power in having an art team as splendid as Capullo + inker + Plascencia every month. As you can tell from this review, I even though I think this is a pretty good comic story, I don’t LOVE it. But Capullo’s consistent presence makes it pretty easy to keep pushing the “Buy” button on my iPad. Just imagine what would happen if there was a mediocre issue of the series and then the next issue had a replacement artist? Maybe you don’t press “Buy” that time… Or the next…
A kudo also needs to go to the back-up story. THAT was aces. I love me some parallels in a story and seeing young Bruce pit-fighting in Scandinavia and refusing to kill anyone, despite the lady saying that killing was the only way to make it stop… That was cool. For a second, I really did kinda wonder how Bruce was going to get out of this mess, until he puts the beat down on like 10 of the guys at once and suddenly nobody else will enter the arena to fight him anymore. I find this interesting because of the obvious, “Why doesn’t Batman just kill the Joker instead of putting him in Arkham where can escape and cause more mayhem?” That is the surface level similarity. But, at a deeper level, perhaps Bruce is striving as Batman in Gotham for the moment when the criminals refuse to fight him anymore? Maybe that is the golden ring that he is chasing? It worked before in the Pit, why wouldn’t it work again in Gotham? Of course, he’s gambling the fate of a city on a single anecdotal experience he had in Norway. Maybe Gotham’s criminals are better or sterner than these Fight Club dudes? Anyway, interesting stuff. It also made me wish that Rafael Albuquerque had gotten to draw an arc of Northlanders before it ended.
Conclusion: A pretty good issue. I think this story is going to be challenging for long-time Batman readers just because we’ve read too much and it’s hard to lever this story into what we already know. New 52 be damned… On the other hand, if you can shrug off that baggage, it is a pretty good issue. And the back-up is aces (how often can you say THAT about a back-up story?).
Grade: B
-Dean Stell
Grade
Conclusion