By: Charles Soule (story), Jesus Saiz (art), Matthew Wilson (colors)

The Story: A place so pleasant and perfect that it could make you scream.

The Review: Having already professed my helpless admiration for Soule’s work, I’ll spare you something similar here, lest I ruin my credibility entirely.  But given that we’re now dealing with the title that’s made his name, I think a little extra eagerness is warranted, don’t you?  Besides, this issue features Anton Arcane, a twisted figure whom Scott Snyder put to good use as a villain, but who was rather shallow a character otherwise.

That’s the nature of inherently sadistic people.  We’ve become so accustomed to the notion that evil is a product of circumstance and upbringing that it’s hard to process that someone may just be born that way.  Yet that’s exactly the theory Soule takes with Arcane, showing the madman as a young lad stumbling upon a decomposing corpse of a slain rabbit in the woods: “I had never seen anything so beautiful.  New feelings churned up inside me.  Excitement.  A young boy’s excitement…”

I’ll spare you the gruesome details of what happens next, but suffice to say, it is sincerely unsettling, enough to inspire an involuntary shudder and perhaps a bit of a retch.  What’s interesting is that the young Arcane has enough perspective to realize the enormity of what he’s done (“I could not understand why I had been compelled to do such an awful thing.”), but something else overwhelms his horror: “[S]oon, I no longer cared.  I did not feel sick.  I felt strong.”  And that’s about the last time he displays something like a conscience.

From that point on, Arcane completely embraces his dark urges, although this doesn’t completely eliminate a sentimental side, twisted as it is.  His obsession with keeping Abigail as his own involved much trauma and few signs of redeeming care, but there’s something different about the way he treats her adoptive mother.  His tenderness toward Ilse is such that he begins to reevaluate the direction of his mission: “What if there could be decay…without death?”  Though the consequences to Ilse are devastating, Arcane is convinced that he’s done her a favor and as he insists, his intent was always to ensure her survival, not the other way around.

Ilse’s fate remains unknown, and it looks like Arcane’s story won’t end in this personal hell of his, “Where nothing rots, and nothing changes.  All is perfect.  Pristine.  Forever.”  Frankly, it was foolhardy of Abby to ever engage with him, which even she acknowledges is “dangerous.”  Considering that it wasn’t all that long ago that Arcane ended up in this state in the first place, it’s a bit disappointing to see signs of an inevitable return.  Let’s hope this is Soule playing a long game; we’ve already had our fill of Arcane.

Most of the art we’ve seen during Villains Month has been bland, fill-in stuff, so getting a whole issue of Saiz’s sensual and dramatic work is a big treat.  If you’ve ever seen his work on Birds of Prey, you know that despite the sheer attractiveness of his figures, there’s always been a quality of horror lurking beneath, a horror that comes out in full-force here.  The crazed look in the young Arcane’s eyes as he does the unspeakable with the rotten rabbit corpse is truly disturbing.  Conversely, Saiz can also bring out the beauty of what ought to be horrifying sights: the demonic Abigail being one example, and a female Swamp Thing being another.  Wilson also impresses; you’re so used to seeing him apply a simple and narrow palette of colors to his issues that the deep, complex array of hues here is dazzling.

Conclusion: Not necessarily revelatory, but an important and insightful look into the villain nonetheless, with some gorgeously lush art besides.

Grade: B+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: – Boy, do I feel sorry for Abby’s French guardians.  Taking in a girl who’s not even related to them and putting up a fight against an unkillable monster, only to be rewarded with a grisly death.  Talk about thankless.

Grade

Conclusion