By: Ed Brubaker (story), Sean Phillips (art), Elizabeth Breitweiser (colors)

The Story: Let this be a lesson to all the boys—“no” means no.

The Review: Once you get to a certain age and gather around you a certain group of friends, specifically one made up of both young men and women, you’ll start having a lot of long, earnest discussions about the differences between men and women.  If you start on that tack, it won’t be long before you start talking about who suffers the break-up more.  In some ways, the debate is moot; we all know that though the symptoms vary, the pain is the same stabbing one we all get.

That said, it’s more common to see the brokenhearted woman in her sweats, curled up in a snuggie, watching TV and eating ice-cream,* but as this issue of Fatale demonstrates, the jilted man is quite a mess himself.  Granted, Brubaker portrays the many abandoned men of Jo’s life at a fairly extreme level of devastation, but their emotional craziness does hint at how deeply the guys can feel the loss of their girl.  What’s really well-done about all this is how convincingly Brubaker can paint so many shades of romantic madness.

I hesitate to say whether each man’s individual psychosis is a larger refection of who he is deep inside.  The variation in their ultimate reactions to Jo seems to support that theory, but it’s all muddled by the fact that Jo’s power drives them to extremes that never in their ordinary, Jo-less lives they would do.  You can see this conflict play out in Lance.  The fact that he made the leap from band member to bank robber with seemingly no hesitation obviously speaks to a certain dangerous streak, but it’s Jo who prompts him to take the next step into violence.

That seems to be the case for a lot of these guys, though for some, it’s less clear how much is the result of Jo’s influence and how much comes from their own natural inclinations.  Wulf’s entire psychology is twisted (“In the end, killing him felt like mercy, which had made Wulf sick.”), but how much of that can really be blamed on one woman’s gesture of compassion during his childhood?  Then again, you see how Skip turns out in this issue, and he started out as the most rational and centered of his bandmates.  If he, as a grown man with previously full control of his faculties, can be turned into a mindless rapist, who’s to say that Wulf’s encounter with Jo during his formative years couldn’t have left behind an even more deeply rooted darkness?  After all, isn’t Nelson, grizzled as he is and long separated from Jo, still under her spell?

I use that last word specifically because this issue once again emphasizes the presence of the supernatural in the story.  By making outright commands that are impossible to resist, Jo has ceased exerting her power passively, which is apparently so significant a shift that a man, sensitive to these kinds of things, reels from it.  Frankly, you’re ready to get on with this kind of material.  Seeing a defunct band crack apart from the inside is fascinating, but a relatively small achievement for the likes of Jo.  You really want to see her strut her stuff against far bigger, less human challenges.

After seeing so many of them in this issue, you can definitely conclude that Phillips has a gift for the crazy faces.  There’s a dark, almost helpless, glint in a lot of these men’s eyes that conveys the compulsions, both psychological and primal, that spurs them on.  Phillips doesn’t achieve this by being louder or broader in his art, but simply by being precise and clear.  If you look at Jon attesting to Jo’s charms, there’s a subtle alteration in his features that indicates that he, too, has fallen: the crinkle of his brow, the enlarged whites around his eyes, the straight, cheerless grin.  Very reminiscent of the expression you see on murderers in their post-homicide mug shots.

Conclusion: You can’t place your finger on any substance that’s driving the plot forward, but like most of Jo’s victims, you’re driven to follow along anyway, to see what heights and depths she can take you.

Grade: B+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Or, in the case of a certain friend of mine after a particularly ugly split, gorging on Fritos covered with a bean dip that made you feel like farting just looking at it.

Grade

Conclusion