By: Matt Fraction (story), Annie Wu (art), Matt Hollingsworth (colors)

The Story: She got more bounce in California than all yours combined.

The Review: Apologies for the long delay between reviews, but I’m sure you understand when I say I really needed to take advantage of the holiday break.  With Thanksgiving behind us, I hope everyone is counting their blessings right around now.  I, for one, am very thankful to have a title like Hawkeye on my monthly pull list.  After so many titles fraught with implausible plots and high drama, it’s refreshing to get a comedic dose of street-based entertainment.

That’s especially the case with this issue, which once again gives Kate Bishop a star turn.  I’d say Kate has really been the breakout character of this series, charming readers with her irresistible blend of confidence, sensitivity, and strong moral compass.  In fact, she reminds me a lot of Stephanie Brown as Batgirl, which is a big plus in my book.  What draws you to both characters is how little division there is between their civilian and costumed selves; whether suited up or not, their personalities remain essentially the same.

This is probably why when Kate finds herself desperate for a job, it never once occurs to her to take the next available opening working the register at a fast-food franchise.  Instead, she immediately sells herself as a “Hero for Hire (no joke)”, ready to take on any case for “a modest little bit of scratch.”  Absolutely no one loves being a superhero more than Kate, and no one proclaims being one with more pride (“Kate Bishop.  I’m pretty much an Avenger.”).  To Kate, being a superhero who has to advertise by tabbed flyers printed by the grace of someone’s charity is still better than not being a superhero.

But Kate also has to face up to the fact that being a superhero with no powers, costume, or support boils down to being little more than a private detective, and although she has plenty of experience saving the world from big, obvious threats, she’s a rank amateur when it comes to the subtleties of real investigative work.  Hence a string of web searches (“criminal,” “arson,” “evidence,” “private detective,” “arson law,” “how to be a private detective in California [sic],”) that ultimately end in frustration (“aljdf:lkjlkj”); amusingly failed attempts to go incognito; and strained encounters with the local authorities.

Speaking of which, Fraction could not have chosen a more archetypical figure for Kate’s police contact than the bald, slack-jowled, middle-aged Detective Caudle, who initially reacts to her with all the indifference and outrage you’d expect from his kind.  Caudle himself calls attention to his formulaic presence in the issue:

“…you think this is the start of some kind of charmingly antagonistic relationship and that I’m going to be helping you out in the future.  With time you’ll find me gruff but endearing as I’ll find you spunky and aggressive but ultimately on the side of the angels.  Am I wrong about…literally any of that, Ms. Bishop?”

Kate also gets some unsolicited help from the classic mysterious stranger in a trenchcoat, a man who of course knows more about her needs than she sometimes does herself.  Throughout the course of the issue, he gives her good servings of metaphor (something of an obsession of hers), sage advice, and practical tips, all without Kate ever once learning his name.  This should be cause for suspicion, especially given his assessment of his own moral character (“[A]t my best, I’m borderline…”) and his inexplicable disappearances.*

Ultimately, Kate’s mission here is less important for what she actually accomplishes (the recovery of a stolen orchid for the symbolic use of a gay wedding) than for how she goes about it.  With too much pride to call out to her friends or mentor to bail her out, Kate is turning her sojourn in L.A. into a test to see if the girl who used to have everything can make do without.  Normally, you’d be pretty confident of the answer, but once you factor in the ongoing vengeance of Madame Masque, it’s a little harder to tell how Kate will extract herself from this situation.

Wu’s linework has a similar delicateness to David Aja’s, though it’s a bit rougher around the edges than David Aja.  It’s that extra bit of detailing that gives the characters their range of expression, however, certainly a lot more than Aja’s minute bits of ink can usually render.  Kate’s facial and body language rings loud and clear even without her generally energetic dialogue, and it’s hard not to fall in love with her once the issue is done.  Hollingsworth’s flat, soft colors are an elegant complement to Wu’s classic figures.

Conclusion: From a textual and artistic standpoint, a Kate-centric issue is easily the equal of a Clint-centric issue and is, appropriately enough, even more focused and purposeful.  Already looking forward to the next one.

Grade: A-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * I’d like to throw out the theory that it could be Clint in disguise, although he’d be stretching himself pretty thin in that case.

– Not that I’m an expert in criminal law matters, but I don’t think California Penal Code Sec. 12022.53 provides for jail time just for possession of a firearm during a felony.  Subsection (b) requires that a defendant “personally use” a firearm to get the extra 10 years in prison.

Grade

Conclusion