By: Rick Rememder (writer), Matteo Scalera (art), Dean White (colors) and Rus Wooton (letters)

The Story: Grant McKay & Colleagues find themselves stranded on another strange world.

Review (with SPOILERS): When the first issue of a new series is as electric as the first issue of Black Science, it is always interesting to see how the next couple of issues shake out.  You always wonder if the comic will be AS good now that you’re expecting awesomeness.

The final analysis is that this issue is good, but not as incredible as the first issue.

The main difference is that the art isn’t given as many opportunities to sing.  The first issue found our protagonists stranded on this bizarre aquatic world where they encountered battling frog-men and fish-men.  It was full of pictures of these weird alien creatures and featured all sorts of opportunities for Dean White to whip out some really electric colors.

This issue just doesn’t go as deep on the building of the alien world they find themselves upon.  There are a few glimpses, but most of the action is the human characters talking to each other.  It’s important work to do – since this is how the overall story is getting built – but it isn’t as exciting as watching Grant McKay ripping the head off a frog-man and using its electric tongue as a whip, or seeing the dancing fish-lady who was about to be eaten by the frog-men……

The good news is that we learn a little more about the background of characters and basic situation.  It isn’t anything too imaginative.  McKay’s scientists have created a dimension hopping device so that they can harvest resources from other realities to cure wants in their own reality.  I guess this has a small flavor of the plundering aliens we often see besetting Earth in science fiction (“They’re here to steal our WATER!”), but I’ll assume that McKay & Co. have some sort of guiding ethics that will keep them from plundering realities with sentient life.  All of this technical work has been funded by Kadir, who plays the stereotypical venture capitalist – greedy, shallow and generally an asshole.  When they test the machine, it “malfunctions” trapping the group on weird “alien” worlds and then begins jumping to other worlds at random.  The group is rounded out by McKay’s children, a sexy scientist who McKay is having an affair with, an officious HR bureaucrat and a crusty veteran who is there to provide “security”.

So, are any of the characters particularly interesting yet?  No….not really.  None of them are offensively bad, but they’re straying a little into the stereotype of nerd fantasy.  For example, I work around scientists all the time and this notion that laboratories are loaded with all sorts of HOT ladies of science is a nerd fantasy that doesn’t match reality.  So, the idea of McKay’s lover is a little problematic.  True to stereotype, she actually understands McKay’s burning passion for science in a way that his wife probably doesn’…and she seems into casual sex with friends and colleagues – another nerd fantasy.  The other character that is a little too stereotypical is Kadir.  I mean, I also know a lot of venture capitalists and this idea that they are all shallow dickheads doesn’t match reality either.  Again, it plays to the nerd myth that venture capitalists are these guys who don’t understand anything and don’t build anything, content to sit back and take credit and crush dreams of creative people.  Even McKay is a little stereotypical right now: He’s driven by his passions to the point of self-destruction.  Again….it’s nerd fantasy that your passion for your project is something that excuses other personal failings because nobody else understands your drive – except for the sexy scientist….she understands.

I don’t want to be too harsh on the characters – yet.  Let’s just say that it is concerning that so many characters are so close to stereotype.  For as imaginative as the art is in Black Science, it would be nice to see similar effort applied to the characters.  On the other hand, lots of money has been generated from books, TV shows and movie that use nothing but stereotype characters….

One lacking element in this issue was the world-itself.  What we saw was awesome; I just wanted MORE.  Nothing is made 100% clear, but it certainly appears that this world is one where the Native American cultures became technologically advanced and have invaded a WWI-era Europe.  That’s a nifty thought.  There have certainly been buckets of books written about why European cultures came to dominate the world, so it’s neat to see an alternate viewpoint.  Since the action appears to be remaining in this reality for another issue or two, I hope this gets explored further because these glimpses of how alternate worlds function could be a very interesting element of the series.

An interesting tidbit on this alt-Earth…..  Isn’t it interesting that they find themselves on an alternate Earth?  I mean, how many different alternate realities are there given all the alien planets throughout the universe…..and they find themselves on another version of Earth?  And on a 4.5 billion year old planet, they find themselves on an alternate Earth that is happening in the last ~100 years?  Hmmm…..now I wonder about that aquatic world…..  Was that an alternate Earth too?  I’d assumed it was an alien planet, but maybe that was another Earth….  And, while we’re on this sort of topic, how about a pseudo-science explanation of how they keep teleporting to new worlds and landing right on the surface of such worlds and never 100 feet underground or somewhere in the vacuum of space?  Even if you’re just hopping between alt-Earths, you have to account for the movement of the Earth in space….

The art is still stellar even if it doesn’t have quite as many opportunities to shine.  This is really career defining work from Scalera.  I love it.  It’s amazing how some artists just have “it” and have a way of drawing with such charisma.  I don’t think I could find fault with a single artistic element in the issue.  I might wish that we got to see more of the Native American technology, but that is a story issue and nothing to do with the quality of the art.

Conclusion: A strong second issue and another interesting world to explore.  Just be careful with the stereotype characters that are all pulled from the Nerd Fantasy textbook.

Grade: B

– Dean Stell

Grade

Conclusion