By: Geoff Johns (story), Ivan Reis (layouts), Joe Prado, Jesus Merino, Vicente Cifuentes (finishes), Rod Reis (colors)

The Story: When your computer crashes, that means it’s time for an upgrade.

The Review: Here’s some totally unsolicited, presumptuous advice to comic book writers: be very careful when making indirect references to the far-flung past of continuity.  Not all your readers are going to be Type-A, obsessive-compulsive critics for Weekly Comic Book Review who feel deep-seated anxiety if they feel like there’s information they’re missing.  Normal people won’t have that same instinct and they’ll simply miss the reference.

With Johns’ revival of the Doom Patrol, missing the reference will definitely diminish your appreciation for this issue’s opening, and may even defeat it altogether.  His decision to introduce the new members of the Patrol then—spoiler alert—have then perish within the span of four pages would seem pointlessly cruel (or cruelly pointless) if you didn’t know he was referring to a similarly short-lived Patrol from the late eighties.  Once you do the research, you’ll notice how Karma and Scott even have similar personalities to their previous incarnation.  Destroying the Patrol this quickly at this moment is thus a deliberate choice that weaves in continuity in the way only Johns can.

But even with that understood, there are still problems with the scene.  No matter what, a four-page introduction and permanent dismissal is a poor way to treat characters,* just to make a point (i.e., the Syndicate is not to be trifled with; there is no hope, etc.).  And of course there’s that Johnsian exposition, so awkward and clunky and with no respect for context.  Why would Karma remind Scott of his own origin story?  For that matter, why would they choose this crisis situation to indulge in melancholy reminiscing?  This is exactly what a one-shot (Forever Evil: Doom Patrol #1) is for: to take abridged anecdotes and turn them into fully-crafted stories.

Despite this rather dispiriting opening, the rest of the issue is a solid and much-needed study into Cyborg.  After Johns established Vic’s constant data connection, it became all too easy to reduce him to a cipher, crowding out his opportunities to be a more active participate in League adventures and putting his own personal dramas on the back-burner.  Setting aside what it means when it takes the indisposition of the entire League to finally give Vic some love, you get some uplifting moments of real heart out of it, much needed in the endless grimness of Forever Evil.

More than that, you get Johns laying foundations for later storylines, as he often does so admirably.  The heart of the heart of the Red Room is revealed to be a ship (“the Mother-Board”) of advanced technology that is nonetheless Earth-born.  In yet another clever connection to continuity, Thomas Morrow “theorizes it’s from the future,” paving the way for his eventual decline into villainy, using the tech of eras to come.

Amazingly enough, despite three different artists finishing Reis’ layouts, it all looks very consistently Reis: that lovely, humanized, tastefully formed figures, just ever so slightly larger than life to make you appreciate that this is a big, mainstream book.  Reis also has a way of understating emotions that sets him apart from his bombastic (Eddy Barrows) or expressionless (David Finch) peers.  I should add, too, that even though I’m sure the design enthusiasts will have a field day with all the additional plates and lines in Cyborg’s new look, it’s a nice contrast from his former bruiser appearance, one that will afford him a chance at a more normal life.

Conclusion: Aside from a rather ineffective opening, the issue makes good on a long-awaited Cyborg-centric story, pitting him as the League’s last stand against all evil.

Grade: B

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Admittedly, we didn’t see Celsius or Tempest die, so there’s a chance members of the original Patrol will survive to adventure again.

– Vic likes Coffee Bean?  Respect, friend.  The Bean’s ice-blended drinks are some of my very favorite things.

Grade

Conclusion