
By: Kelly Sue DeConnick (Writer), David Lopez (Art), Lee Loughridge (Color Artist), VC’s Joe Carmagna (Letterer)
The Story: Eleanides never listens! She never lets Captain Marvel do anything! Fine, she’ll just go and do it herself.
The Review: This issue picks up directly after issue one, for some reason. The last four months were in fact flashback for the en media res decision to have Captain Marvel chase Tic through some kind of market place in #1. I’m not sure that if it also explains why she is holding the green MacGuffinite metal (a.k.a. vibranium) on page one, but we’ll take it as a given so the rest of the plot can continue, and thus we find out it’s the reason for the villain(s) interest in the planet of Torfa.
It’s also a good thing that Captain Marvel gathered together a ragtag bunch of misfits to be her sidekicks (you know, the ones helping create the cliffhanger last issue, striding forward into action?)– they help provide some background filler while they stand behind Captain Marvel as she engages in dialogue for 3/4 of the book. In fact, CM and her crew have come to report to Eleanides that they were out having an adventure that I swear we didn’t even get to see.
To be fair, the political conflict that tosses around our characters is nicely complex, with whole populations caught up in one no-win situation after another, and quite poignant individual responces. Unfortunately, some characters, like Eleanides, of whom I had an instant liking in her first appearance, suffers because of this, too. One minute she’s ordering evacuations, then not, or she’s refusing to listen, then she does, then she doesn’t, then she wants to rise up, then she surrenders. So much for my liking of her.
Captain Marvel remains stalwart and defiant, but also largely ineffective, much in the same way she’s been for the past four issues. At least she gets a good dramatic double-page spread facing down a space fleet. But I’m sensing a pattern, here. I hope I’m wrong, and next issue we get to see some space battle, but my guess is that we will just see Carol arriving down on the planet to explain something else to Eleanides as if the battle took place while we are waiting for the next issue to arrive.
That ending splash is a good example of the strengths of the art– something beautifully arranged, dynamic, and imaginative. And yet, there’s something about its potential that could be even greater. There is some degree of variety in ship designs, but it could be pushed even further. There’s some sense of size relationship between the ships, but it could be pushed MUCH further. There could even be a more dramatic shot with Captain Marvel drawn smaller in the foreground, visually heightening the enormity of her stance with ships nearly engulfing her.
The art really shines with the character designs and layouts. While conversation dominates much of the book, the characters are arranged nicely and there’s usually movement as the setting shifts from place to place. As always, characters are cartoony (I prefer the term “graphic”) without being unrealistic. The line weight and the colors also help to ground the characters with a sense of weight and solidity that makes it a fully-realized world.
The Bottom Line: There continues to be some narrative missteps here in the overall story, despite a nicely operatic political drama. Our characters still hint and complexity and being engaging, but have yet to fully come into their own. With most of the visual action happening offscreen, it’s hard to recommend the book as an effective superhero action showcase, but the art remains beautiful and expressive.
Grade: C+
-Danny Wall
Two Other Tidbits:
— The groundwork continues to closely align Captain Marvel and Guardians of the Galaxy books
— It’s a nice bit to include vibranium as the MacGuffin here. It’s been said that vibranium came to Earth as a meteorite, but I’m not sure anyone’s ever been as specific as here to explain where it came from in space in the first place.
Grade
Conclusion