
By: Dan Slott (Plot) Christos Gage (Script), Giuseppe Camuncoli (Penciller), John Dell (Inker), Antonio Fabela (Color Artist), Chris Eliopoulos (Letterer), Adam Kubert (Back-Up Artist), Rain Beredo (Back-Up Colorist)
The Story: This looks like a job for Spider-Man. And Spider-Man, and Spider-Man, and Spider-Man, … etc.
The Review: I’m not sure how typical a comic fan I am– I read a lot of comics but virtually no comics-related news and certainly no comics previews. My digital subscriptions show up automatically, and I browse the cover gallery for things that might catch my eye in a given week. So it was with a bit of surprise that I find a new Superior Spider-Man on sale. Thankfully, the cover tells me that “Edge of Spider-Verse (sic?) begins with this over-sized spectacular!” So, since I was also among those who really enjoyed the Octavius-Spidey era (again, not sure how typical a comic fan that makes me) let’s see what this is all about…
Well, any story that has to provide BOTH a “Previously” page and a two-page spread of exposition isn’t off to a great start, I’d think. After another page of exposition, Spidey-Ock stands on a rooftop in a full-page splash that’s meant to show we are in an exciting new future of 2099… by showing us some nondescript buildings? At least throw in a few flying cars or Futurama-style pnematic tubes or something. Aside from the bands on some cone-shaped buildings waaaay in the distance, you’d be hard-pressed to say this was a future cityscape. Things improve a little bit in the subsequent panels with fashion and (finally) flying cars and laser guns, but overall, capital-S Setting should be an important element in this book, especially as Spidey-Ock starts traveling to other times, but these locations don’t seem to be treated with any special care in the art. Instead, it’s all merely in service for the real focus, the set-up for our crossover plot.
There’s also little attempt to humanize Spidey-Ock (it’s mostly peripheral thanks to making Anna-Marie into his assistant), and it only takes a few panels before he’s already made himself at home in 2099 with everything he/the plot needs. So far, the other alternate Spider-Man are just regulated to cameos of their dead bodies, which leads up to a relatively closer look at the Spider-Man of India, who will finally becomes a part of the main cast and likely a point-of-view character for the audience later. This meeting also provides most of the action, as he faces down our vague and sinister/menacing steampunkish villain, but the sequence is still confusing. Aside from failing to showcase the setting, it’s hard to understand how Peter Prabhakar/Spider-Man of India uses his webs to prop up a falling building, and also how the villain must have walked around Prabhakar to retrieve his weapon and then must have walked BACK to stand behind him again. Perhaps the laws of physics are different where he comes from?
The back-up pages feature the narrative captions of a different Spider-Man, but one that I’m unfamiliar with. And this is coming from the guy who literally wrote the Unofficial Handbook to the Marvel Universe. This story does a better job of establishing character, due to the narration, but it’s without context, or even a name for this guy, so there’s nothing to really latch onto as a reader. It makes the whole thing feel a bit empty. (I’m guessing it must be based on some “What If?” story that spun out of the Spider-Man/Wolverine story that was popular in the 80s.)
The Bottom Line: The story does what it says on the cover– provides a set-up for the upcoming Spider-Verse crossover, but it does so with only one really “likeable” version, the Spider-Man of India. As such, there’s many missed opportunities of setting and character and suspence, with only the promise of the gimmick to see as many Spider-Versions as possible as the real “hook.” Granted, that’s a pretty neat hook likely to bring me back, especially since I trust in what Slott/Gage can deliver, but it makes me hesitate to recommend this book unless you’re looking for a complete collection.
The Grade: C+
-Danny Wall
Other Tidbits:
— What a neat touch that Otto sees visions of Marvel’s alternate realities/futures as he enters the cliché swirling vortex of time… I count Maestro’s future, Earth X, Deathlok, 1602, Days of Future Past, and MC2. Help me out if I’m wrong!
Grade
Conclusion