By: Dan Slott (Writer), Humberto Ramos (Penciller), Victor Olazaba (Inker), Edgar Delgado (Color Artist), Chris Eliopoulos (Letterer)

The Story: Spidey v. Black Cat on live TV! Jameson calls an exclusive; I call it a re-run.

The Review: Slott & Ramos continue their streak of entertaining Spider-Man stories, but when I stopped to map out some of the plot points for my review, I started to wonder how it was truly fitting all together.

For example, the Black Cat and Electro prove to be a pretty effective team-up– they easily face down the organized crime of New York, after all. But… why, exactly? Such confrontations are cool and dramatic, if the Black Cat’s all about taking out Spider-Man, why does she have to “take” any of the Maggia’s stuff at all? What did the duo do to the Eel’s operation, anyway, once the scene was cut away? Why confront Mister Negative and the Goblin King to just announce that she’s going to take down the spider? Why dismiss Spider-Man’s pleas for reason? The Black Cat is simultaneously being built up (as a powerful threat) and being reduced (to an unthinking, raving shrew.)

Jameson looked like he was being put into a genuinely new position but one that fit logically and progressively as a crusading TV pundit. On some level, his character more or less works best in broad strokes, of course, but there’s so much more to just hoping to expose Spider-Man’s identity on television. And when this plot point was already the focus of a major real-world marketing campaign many years ago, it’s hard to take such a cliffhanger seriously.

The character Silk has a good showing against the Black Cat here, and is set up to provide Peter Parker with some awkward situations due to her lack of social skills. In fact, she’s quite expressly identified as a sidekick, but in other ways, the character seems to accept what’s happening around her quite easily, which doesn’t seem to fit. There’s a bit of existential horror to her situation of being hidden away for ten years, but it’s not really capitalized on. If both Spider-Man and Silk don’t seem to put much stock in her situation or the implications, except for laughing nervously as their minds are reduced to basic impulses, it’s difficult for the reader to take it seriously, too.

The art is nicely expressive, as always, although there were more than a few basic errors of anatomy and positioning this time. Sometimes the backgrounds, too, seem oversimplified and roughly angled, or even dropped entirely and relying on the colorist to provide large areas of washed color. The cliffhanger, in particular, is deflated a bit since the light source casts all the figures in large areas of black and the background is simply some white spots. Electro’s power display is as vibrant as ever, of course, which is nice– the glows are powerful but still remain a threat to the clarity of a panel.

The Bottom Line: Spidey’s life is as crazy as ever, but it’s difficult to know what to make of it. The lines between comedy and suspense are not quite as clear as the characters themselves are swept up into the demands of the story. I’m waiting for the moment we can clearly see Peter Parker as a hero and not simply being a victim to the forces around him. Even if the Black Cat chooses to ignore all logic and (disappointedly) become a supervillain, at least she’s showing some agency.

Grade: C+

-Danny Wall

Grade

Conclusion