By: James Robinson (Writer), Marc Laming (Penciller), Scott Hanna (Inker, 4-6), Jesus Aburtov (Color Artist), VC’s Clayton Cowles (Letterer), Leonard Kirk & Israel Silva (Cover Artists)

The Story: Problems are always made worse when running into your ex-girlfriend.

The Review: First of all, the cover. It’s something quite fun and exuberant, and it’s not often you can say that for today’s comics. Partly that comes from the smiles on the children’s faces, which, again, is not something that you’re likely to see on any given cover nowadays. (Assuming, of course, that Franklin’s expression is, in fact, a smile. How unfortunate that the most prominent face on the cover is also the most poorly depicted.) Also fun? The Kirby-crackle in the Human Torch’s powers, with flames that are also more bubbly instead of edgy.

Inside, it’s artist Laming’s turn to provide art, and he has a key set piece in presenting an Escher-like scientific Eden. By contrast, one of the other scenes really require much else, such as a window-paneled SHIELD headquarters and gray walls of a prison. What I’d like to see more of, overall, is some variety of expression by the characters. In general, everyone just slightly opens his/her mouth, as everyone is in a constant state of saying “uhhh….” until there is an occasional subtle smile. Push those expressions more, please, and have characters act/pose in a greater variety than simply lifting a hand to indicate they are talking.

I count a total of eight blows given by supervillains, making the first time in half a year or so that there’s been a hero-villain showdown, thanks to the Thing being imprisoned. It’s all a set-up for a surprising reveal of the She-Thing, which promises some interesting interaction for sure, at least for those that remember she was once Ms. Marvel, a member of the Fantastic Four, and love interest for Ben Grimm. (Still, some part of me wonders if there is a logical piece of the story missing– as in the actual investigation of Grimm’s accusation of murder. I get the sense that this is just taken for granted since the story that is “important” is the Thing’s life in prison, but it reflects poorly on any other aspect of the FF’s world.)

There’s some more curious choices, such as having the cover’s signature scene actually be a flashback told by Jim Hammond to his superior officer, and the Invisible Woman who doesn’t do anything except talk on the phone to provide a framing device/exposition.

All in all, it’s a positive direction for the story, as there’s less set-up and characters are starting to feel their way around their new status quo. This is the most interesting the storyline has been so far, and where it will all lead is genuinely in flux at this point, rather than being a foregone conclusion.         

The Bottom Line: It’s a new arc for this ongoing storyline, one that is putting every character into his/her own dark place. This is balanced by a “win” for the kids of the future foundation, and a very surprising return of a forgotten character. The art proves capable but somewhat limited in truly emoting this dark new place, but the overall momentum of story continues to pique interest.   

Grade: B

Danny Wall

Other Tidbits:

— Fashion alert! Mr. Fantastic is sporting an official Fantastic Four polo, black, with red trim and logo. A nice and subtle element. Interestingly, it automatically sets him a part from his fellow Eden scientists, who follow the plain, white, and chrome aesthetic.

— This issue makes it a month when Marvel is publishing comics that feature Carol Danvers, Kamala Khan, Monica Rambeau, AND Sharon Ventura? Marvelous.

Grade

Conclusion