By: Rick Remender (Writer), Sanford Greene (Penciller), Dean White (Color Artist), VC’s Clayton Cowles (Letterer), Agustin Alessio (Cover Artist)

The Story: Whaddya know? Sometimes stories that say they were an event that “changes everything” actually do change pretty much everything.

The Review: The previous run on Uncanny Avengers could rightly be described as “epic,” and as I opened this issue, I was consciously hoping that we could get a more “downtime” story, as characters felt their way around its fallout and their new status quo. Thankfully, this issue was exactly what we needed.

Interestingly, the story begins a few weeks past the denouement of last issue, in case fans needed to reconcile whatever jumbled continuity got created by that a year-long story. What follows for 95% of the issue is really just characters talking to one another, but they treat each other as comrades-in-arms, as fellow veterans, as friends (or even more) as appropriate. The events of their time-traveling epic may have been erased, but that doesn’t mean they never happened, and these people have to deal with that.

Immortus, whose role in the previous arc was somewhat tenuous and thus relatively a weak link in an otherwise dense plot, shows up to offer, of all things, encouragement and promise, as long as they deal with the Red Skull, a teaser for the upcoming storyline and segue into an ominous Skull-focused cutscene. It’s an effective scene, taking the heinous Skull and matching him to the equally-heinous Ahab, throwing them both into Genosha. This is “high concept” that works, since there’s an immediate tension and horror-tinged atmosphere to lead into next issue.

It’s also the reason that a combination of Avengers and X-Men’s “universes” allow for such interesting stories to be told. All the other elements of the issue reflect this, too, with Havok and the Wasp becoming an earnest couple at last, and a Rogue-Scarlet Witch-Wonder Man triangle that can only happen in the comics. Rogue’s pathos is, of course, the most palpable. It’s always an interesting narrative to take away the one “thing” that the character has worked so hard to achieve and to see how she deals with it. Still, because that one thing is Rogue’s lack of control for her powers, it somehow also feels like a step backward for the character. I’m just not convinced that there’s much to be explored with that handicap that hasn’t already been done, except, of course, for the fact that had gotten so used to not having it.

Rogue’s anguish is nicely rendered by Greene’s art, neatly matching the histrionics of her dialogue. When confronting Rogue, the Scarlet Witch, by contrast is nearly emotionless and static in her posing. This doesn’t seem to match the gravitas of her words (“The man I love is trapped inside your head”) or the seeming intention of the scene as a kind of reconciliation. Instead, if it’s a deliberate choice, it makes the Witch come across as a bit disingenuous. Is it a kind of artistic error, or is the “Unity Squad” again headed for trouble because of the Witch-Rogue dynamic?

In other areas, the art becomes too “loose” for its own good, distorting characters’ faces and rendering them a bit off-model. Wolverine comes across one time as a thug we’d see in the background of a Dick Tracy strip, even though he was spot-on in hawkish handsomeness a few pages prior. Wasp too often looks like a anime girl someone doodled in the margin of their History notes, and I wondered at time if the Immortus we were seeing came from the Marvel Apes universe. The Red Skull looks like he’s stepped from the pages of MAD Magazine. Other distortions exist, too, with bodies loosely rendered to be more stick-like than human, especially if the layout angle shifts, but I will give credit for a variety of attempts to actually use a variety of layout angles when there’s such a dialogue-driven comic.

The Bottom Line: This issue is exactly what we needed when coming off of a big event, and the characters ring true although there’s some question and tension about that which is sure to drive some of the subplots forward. It’s more an issue about tone, from the fallout of our previous epic to the setup of the next. Unfortunately, the art could have used a dedicated inker/finisher to really smooth out more than a few rough areas.

The Grade: A-

by Danny Wall

Other Tidbits:
— Immortus announces his Infinity Watch will be heroes of the timeline in some ways we won’t see, which is a nice teaser for a comic that I would love to read but will never actually exist.
— Does this mean Havok will be getting a new costume?

Grade

Conclusion