
By: Jim Zub (Writer), Steve Cummings (Artist), John Rauch and Jim Zub (Color Artists), Marshall Dillon (Letterer), Zack Davisson (Back Matter)
The Story: Rori Lane gets Spirited Away…
The Review: I wasn’t sure if I was ready to follow a new title, but the cover art was nice and the premise was a familiar but favorite set-up. And I’m really glad I did. This was a great comic, presented with true craft and care.
The story is pretty basic in its broad strokes– a young woman moves to Japan and finds a secret, supernatural reality to its urban mundaneness. So what can the creators do to explore this common trope? Simply by staying so earnestly true to the characters and to the world-building. The main character, Rori, displays appropriate emotions (loss, frustration, confusion, wonder) without resorting to melodrama. She’s coming to Japan for the first time, to help readers who are also new to this world, but she’s not so fish-out-of-water as to be helpless or cliché. This could easily be taken as a slice-of-life or travelogue story, except of course for the strange powers she discovers and the creatures she encounters.
What really shines here is the depiction of Tokyo. Having lived in Tokyo for five years, I have mixed feelings when I see it show up in entertainment. Too often it resorts to grand generalizations if not downright stereotype, and even after living there for five years I find it difficult to understand some otaku’s passion for the romanticized vision they have of it. Instead, the writer and artists here show us a completely realistic depiction, free from cliché and overwrought examples. Rori, for example, alights from the subway in Ikebukuro and is still just as overwhelmed with the experience as she would be if she emerged into Shibuya– the go-to example that *everyone* uses to announce to the reader/viewer “this is Japan.” We see Rori experiencing underground malls, escalator-less stairwells, crowded alleyways, and cramped apartments.
Every panel is lovingly detailed. Corrugated rooftops, set tables in the restaurant, public transport with individuals and background action, even the locks on the doors of the apartment– are all what you will find in Japan. You can even read the vending machines labels and almost every sign in the background.
This simple day-to-day living is presented with great care and highlights the appearance of the supernatural. Its a nice example of “magical realism” with just a suggestion of an unseen reality, whose worlds we want to see explored in coming issues.
Some of the writing is a bit exposition-heavy, which might be forgivable since this is a first issue, but by and large it slips into hokeyness a little too much, especially in the beginning, such as when she meets her mom. “The divorce took its toll on all of us, but this is a fresh start.” For such attention to “reality” in the art, dialogue such as this feels forced and fake. Other times, things are left appropriately vague, and that’s okay. We can learn over time what happened to Rori’s dad, or what Rori’s past was really like.
Her powers are left vague, too, as is the nature of the magical reality. This is more or less the cliffhanger to have us come back to. I’m a bit disappointed in the display of Rori’s power, due to some layout choices that don’t guide the reader very well. When she announces “each route has its own pattern,” we naturally read from left-to-right/top-down, but her sequence of jumping starts at the bottom of the panel, then moves right-to-left then right again, breaking the 180 Degree Rule and disrupting the flow of an otherwise exciting fight scene. In the next panel, a very thin layout does not give us any visual context (and again the point of view shifts 180 degrees, too) and presents glowing footprints that at first glance look too solid and could just as easily be falling frankfurters. The next panel, too, shifts the angle of p.o.v., this time looking down into the alley but also collapsing for some reason and taking out all the monsters while Rori’s helper flees– all of which happens in less than one quarter of the page? An unfortunate and unnecessarily confusing sequence.
The back matter has some very heart-felt words by the creators as well as some more academic writing about Japanese culture and information about our monsters. It’s true that stories of monsters and folklore have always been an integral part of Japanese life, and it is one of the more fascinating aspects of the culture. I also think it’s a neat touch that Rori has Irish ancestry as well, which arguably is just as steeped in monsters and folklore, too, and I really hope we’re set up to get some true blending of such worlds. I do wonder, however, about the afterword’s self-made comparisons to Buffy the Vampire Slayer. Buffy worked because of the way it turned tropes on their ear, and I’m not sure we’re being set up for any irreverent take on such themes in Wayward, which seems to be working precisely because it’s playing to type.
The Bottom Line: What we get in Wayward is a coming-of-age story with a touch of magical reality. The characters and plot seems a bit straight-forward so far, but what really sells issue is the fantastic depiction of setting that sets up the dichotomy between the reality and the magic in beautifully detailed scenes.
Grade: A-
-Danny Wall
Other Tidbits:
Rory: “It’s a bit depressing when you realize everything you own can fit in two bags.”
Me: “My latest move took me down to ten. It’s annoying, yes, but actually quite liberating.”
Grade
Conclusion
Jim Zub, John Rauch, Steve Cummings, Wayward