By: David Hine with Fabrice Sapolsky (Writers), Richard Isanove (Artist), VC’s Clayton Cowles (Letterer & Production)

If you are going to be bold enough to put “noir” in your title, then you’ve set your readers to expect a certain style. Thankfully, the creators are up to the task here, and Isanove displays a nice grasp of the aesthetic, featuring heavy areas of black with an absence of hatching/stippling. The effect makes the issue very “painterly” and tinged with an old-school atmosphere. Some of the color choices are a bit too bright in places, perhaps, relying on glows/gradients that don’t quite fit. The scene in Felicia Hardy’s apartment, for example, could be pushed a lot more into darkness to really capitalize on the emotions there. Still, the lead Spider-Man looks, well, amazing– otherworldly and real-worldly at the same time.

The story is essentially all about Spider-Man-Noir and almost none about the set-up of the Spider-Verse. I kind of like that. In fact, Spider-Noir pretty much wins over his villains in a nice done-in-one story that could have been any given issue of a Noir on-going series. And while I haven’t read the Noir mini-series that inspired this issue, I feel that I immediately can embrace this world and its characters as they are so familiar. A lot of it has to do with the advantage of being a parallel world, a trope for which I’m a sucker in the first place, but there’s some genuine earnest to the characters, and the en media res continuity is easy to pick up.

Perhaps there’s a bit of criticism in that it’s almost a bit *too* parallel? In a world labelled Noir, shouldn’t there be a bit more darkness in all our characters? Wouldn’t Aunt May be some chain-smoking, failed Flapper girl and MJ some ambitious, tweaking nympho? Where’s the overwrought Raymond Chandler-style narration? But in a modern comic where Wolverine can’t chomp a cigar and no one uses thought bubbles anymore, perhaps a truly Noir style comic isn’t possible. And since this is really meant to tie into a larger story, I’d imagine Spider-Noir won’t be as central to the story as it continues, so we have to judge this chapter according to “standard” comicbook styles and settings.       

Having read the Superior Spider-Man lead-in to this comic, I would have expected a bigger presence for the Spider-Octavious character and the Spider-Man-India character. (Whew, this will be a lot of typing if I continue these reviews.) There is extremely little continuity between the two issues, which is OK I guess, but this issue’s structure, pacing, and world/character building is much more effective, and I wish something similar might have been appropriate as the lead-in chapter. 

The Bottom Line: It looks like the Spider-Verse will be a fun ride, if the story allows each Spider-Man to really showcase his/her unique flavor, as this issue does.

The Grade: A-

-Danny Wall

Other Tidbits:
— I love that Noir’s story includes not only previous continuity, but also sets up future subplots such as Felicia’s escape with some Spider-blood. I’m not sure if this means the world itself will be a player, or if it’s just a nice Easter egg-like bit.
— It still bugs me that there’s a missing “the” in the title somewhere. There’s a little bit of a pedant in all of us, sometimes. (That’s your SAT vocab word of the day.)

Grade

Conclusion