By: James Robinson (Writer), Marc Laming (Penciller), Scott Hanna and Marc Laming (Inkers), Jesus Aburtov (Color Artist), VC’s Clayton Cowles (Letterer), Leonard Kirk & Jason Keith (Cover Artist)

The Story: She-Thing-on-Thing action, Johnny’s futile intervention, Sue’s mysterious excursion, the Frightful Four’s latest permutation

The Review: “THIS.” Forgive the meme-speak, but it was my honest reaction after reading this issue. It took a long time, too much time in my opinion, to get here, but Robinson is finally adding to and/or genuinely remixing the Four’s mythos rather than simply and ham-fistingly forcing characters to go where he wants. If we can continue to go in this direction, I think we might actually have characters and situations that feel like they evolve, instead of simply having set pieces that get rearranged.

The focus here is on the core Four, with the children being sidelined. I guess the sense of finality to their subplot last issue was indeed more of a wrap-up, which is fine; there’s enough plot going on to keep the pages plenty crowded. Unfortunately, however, Robinson continues to present the characters in a series of vignettes or distinct chapters, which lends a bit of a schizophrenic feeling to the reading experience. In other words, it might as well be an anthology series, with a chapter for the Thing, Sue, Reed, and Johnny. I suppose I could see this as a metacommentary which reinforces the distinct split the team has experienced, but in fact it just ends up being a bit jarring.

It’s nice to see some acknowledgement, too, that there is someone behind the scenes of the Four’s recent troubles. The Thing flat-out declares he’s being set up, but unfortunately it only heightens how illogical the characters are acting. If it really is so obvious a set-up (and, really, even if it isn’t) it makes you wish the characters would actually be doing something about it. You know, the same characters that literally battered down the doors of heaven to rescue Ben at some point. Let’s hope that’s the whole point of the Invisible Woman’s, ahem, disappearance.

She-Thing/Ms. Marvel’s story is kind of tragic, but reminiscent of the “real-world” Marvel of the “Bronze Age.” Sometimes momentum of a character is just as much downward as it is upward. The Thing could use a rogue’s gallery of his very own, and it might be nice to see a dramatic foil succumb to her monstrous side to highlight how well Ben has managed to overcome his own. When’s the last time we saw that? The 70s’ Darkoth the Death-Demon? (Yes, I’m a Marvel geek, I thought you knew that.)

Or maybe it’s just 70s-palooza in FF-land, with the Wizard pulling from the old Salem’s Seven group in order to form a new Frightful Four, which naturally brings in the Scarlet Witch for some Marvel Team-Up action. We’re getting more explicit acknowledgement that there’s a force behind this, but if this is going to be a mystery, shouldn’t we be getting some clues about it, too, instead of just repeating “Wow, it’s almost like there’s a force behind all of this”?  (Although I do like the Wizard using the Frightful Four as a kind of supervillain temp agency, forming new teams with strange new contenders each time.)

Once again, the story offers some opportunities for action, with a prison fight and a hero-villain throw-down in Chicago. The fight scenes are nice, and I’m liking what Laming can bring to them. Because they are really just one or two page scenes, however, there’s some limit to how much we witness as exchange of blows, and instead the emphasis is on the dialogue or exposition during such scenes. The remainder of scenes are all dialogue, too, making me think that’s the real interest of Robinson’s. That’s a shame because Laming will then default to characters standing around looking at each other and raising a hand or something to indicate who’s talking.       

The Bottom Line: The fractured tales of a fractured Fantastic Four makes for an almost anthology-style reading experience, but this time it’s mixing the familiar and the old school, resulting in the story finally going to some interestingly new places. I can honestly say I wasn’t expecting the final page appearance, but it’s things like that which will keep me interested.

The Grade: B+

-Danny Wall

Other Tidbits:
— Did you notice the shout-out to Red Wolf? I always liked that guy when I was a kid, clichés and all. Maybe because I was jealous of him having a pet wolf.
— The former fanfic writer in me now wants to do a spin-off alternate Fantastic Four team of Wingfoot, Red Wolf, She-Thing, and Scarlet Witch.

Grade

Conclusion