By: Dan Slott (Writer), Humberto Ramos (Penciller), Victor Olazaba (Inker), Edgar Delgado (Color Artist), VC’s Joe Caramagna (Letterer)

The Story: All of this could have been avoided if the Black Cat didn’t need an initiation ritual to lead some random Z-list bad guys.

The Review: There has to be a kind of optimism in every hero. There has to be, because it seems like it takes a lot of work to try to right the wrongs of the world without a lot of payoff. That observation is made by a few people in Spider-Man’s new supporting cast, Anna Marie and Sanjani, but Parker counts the events of this issue as a “win” because of his heroic optimism. This is a neat way to keep Spider-Man poised as a prime example of heroism in the Marvel universe, and it highlights one of the reasons that he’s been a favorite character for many years.

Other developments in this issue? Not so satisfying. For some reason, there’s an attraction between Spider-Man and Silk, which is annoying Anna Marie just as much as the readers. The whole thing seems to be playing more to comedy than anything, which is part of the annoyance, because all the characters don’t really take it seriously. I’m not sure it’s the best take, as it actually detracts from actual character-building. Wouldn’t Peter, the quintessential “responsible” hero, be dealing with this more deeply? Shouldn’t there be some logical questions and consequences to this? So far, aside from some eye-rolling from Anna Marie, there doesn’t appear to be. They do admit their attraction is stronger when there’s danger nearby, but that doesn’t really make sense. “Hey! Something bad is going to happen! Let’s stop and kiss!”

Developments like this rely on PIS, or “Plot-Induced Stupidity.” That’s been the reason behind my complaints of the Black Cat’s portrayal throughout this storyline, but even Anna Marie’s not immune, as she doesn’t recognize that the Cat (with glasses) isn’t a part of her own company. I’ll give Electro’s stupidity credit, though; he’s always been a bit dim, so to speak.

Now, there is a glimmer of more complex motivation in the Black Cat, when she identifies Spider-Man as the “unluckiest part of [her] life.” If the Cat were somehow developing an obsession about luck and transferring this onto Spider-Man, it could actually be an interesting philosophical moment. Perhaps she should be conflicted about luck/randomness and control/personal choice, and by trying to control/destroy Spider-Man, she would be somehow trying to gain agency over the tragedies of her life. When juxtaposed against Spider-Man’s own random tragedies, often referred to as “the Parker Luck” over the years, then you actually have a reason for pushing the Cat in this direction. There might be more opportunity for this, as the Black Cat declares how she wants to be the “queen of this whole town,” certainly displaying a desire for control that she’s never shown before.   

Once again, the hyper-kinetic Ramos art works well in some instances, and not particularly well in others. When the scene switches to The Waterfront, for example, there’s a very poor layout choice when the Cat and Electro infiltrate the scene– a key plot point that is too cramped to be effective. This might be a pacing problem, as Slott needs, essentially, two different scene-establishing layouts on the same page. Earlier in the book, the sequence of panels could have been more parallel to emphasize the Set-Up/Reversal kind of visual punchlines. Of course, in the battle scenes, though, the displays of power are awesome, with webbing, lightning, and whips all perfectly suited for the zig-zagging vibrant pencils and colors. I also think that some of the facial expressions have been a bit toned down now, and don’t appear as anatomy-bendingly exaggerated as before. Or at least not distractingly so.   

The Bottom Line:
A more typical ending might have had Electro meet some more disastrous end, so for Parker to chalk up what happened as a “win” is fitting. It wasn’t easily won, and various players are being put in place for future conflict, so despite the wrap-up, we get plenty of narrative momentum so perfect for serialized fiction. I can’t say all the characters are acting consistently or logically, however.

The Grade: B

-Danny Wall

Other Tidbits:
— Wait, there’s yet another Melter now? For a one-note, only-fits-with-Iron-Man-in-the-60s villain, and a dead guy, he sure gets trotted out a lot.
— Did 8-Ball ever team-up with the Orb? I wonder if the Headmen are hiring?

Grade

Conclusion