By: Jeff Lemire (story), Jed Dougherty (art), Gabe Eltaeb (colors)

The Story: Among his many powers, Captain Atom demonstrates his nuclear temper.

The Review: One of the complications of reading comics (and part of why it can get a little tricky to review these things) is the synthesis of story and art, the way they build, play upon, and tear each other down. Strong art doesn’t always follow strong story, and vice versa, yet they do tend to gravitate toward each other, in the same way a Martin Scorsese film will attract the likes of Leonardo DiCaprio, Daniel Day-Lewis, and Cate Blanchett, while Michael Bay has Megan Fox to grace his screen.

So just by looking at Dougherty’s art for this issue, you can get the measure of its story, and neither is very good. It should never be lost on anyone how often DC’s September line-wide Events are absent of the publisher’s usual stable of artists, replaced by those whose only apparent talent is to turn out an issue of minimally clear visuals by a given deadline. Such is the work of Dougherty, whose generic, slightly disheveled figures look as if they were churned out while he was daydreaming in class. Perspective is just barely present, and the energy blasts drawn as shapeless, fluttery blooms—the kind you might have drawn as an eager fifth-grader—is about as dynamic as the action gets.

It’s entirely possible, however, Dougherty is just following Lemire’s lead, for Lemire also seems to be running on autopilot on the script. It’s the been-there-done-that plot that gives superhero comics a bad name: a former hero (Captain Atom) goes mad and turns on his old teammates (a hodgepodge Justice League). Even worse, this scenario of an unstable Atom is one that’s been recycled at least a couple times in DC history, which may explain the lethargy radiating from the characters as they play it out once more. Lemire tries to spur their emotions by inflating his numbers (“The millions of lives I took, I took to save billions.”), but you just don’t buy it.

There isn’t even much fun in seeing the future League either. The composition is interesting enough, with members from the original League, the JLU, the Legion of Super-Heroes, and even the Others thrown together in a quota style reminiscent of Keith Giffen’s JLI. But you can add a couple New Gods and even an Avenger for good measure and still get nothing out of it if you don’t let them bounce off each other, and Lemire’s never been that great at such interplay.

He doesn’t help himself either by multiplying the number of villains. Again, it’s a decent mix of characters—Mongul, Grodd, Killer Frost, and Count Vertigo among them—but Atom is correct when he says they are “of little significance…merely a means to an end.” But to what end? To destroy the forcefield imprisoning them all on Mars? Seems like that’d be an easy task for Atom alone, who claims he can “bend space and time on a quantum level.” To get him to the shuttle that can take him off-planet? Why would he even need it if he is a creature of pure energy? It just sounds like none of this is very well though-out.*

It’s hard to conceive what Lemire was thinking in taking on all these characters at once and creating such a hyperbolic threat for the purposes of a single issue—one at the reduced page-count, too. It doesn’t take much sense to realize getting out of such a predicament in that amount of time will be either impossible or ludicrous, and here we have the latter. Since the ragtag League is definitely outclassed by the godlike Atom, it’s up to Martian Manhunter to once again psychically wrestle the threat into submission, in a scene so desperately pathetic and anticlimactic that a planetary explosion might have been preferable.

Conclusion: A comic book that’s clearly going through the motions. There isn’t even much value in skimming.

Grade: D+

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Not to mention Atom’s final plan to destroy the forcefield surrounding Mars by destroying Mars itself, an idea that admittedly only makes sense in the tragically deluded.

Grade

Conclusion