By: Peter David (Writer), Pop Mhan (Breakdowns), Pop Mhan and Scott Hanna (Finishes), Lee Loughridge (Color Artist), VC’s Cory Petit (Letterer), Kris Anka & Jared Fletcher (Cover Artist)

The Story: Bonds of sisterhood can be fixed with copious amounts of beer and beating up on others’ abusive boyfriends.

The Review: Last issue was a trip to Colonial Williamsburg, and now it’s to a Renaissance Faire. If next issue becomes a trip to a Civil War Re-enactment, I’m not sure if I’ll laugh or cry. It does make an interesting balance, though, in that last issue was all about Quicksilver using the setting as a way to make family time with his daughter, and this time it’s all about Polaris and Scarlet Witch’s attempt at sisterhood. In this case, Danger is brought along as well, to complete our girl’s day out and pass the Bechel Test. (Actually, it’s a quite natural development of ongoing storylines, meaning that X-Factor consistently has, as its strength, distinct characters and intriguing relationships of all kinds.)

The characteristic humorous quirks and quick-witted quips are all on display here, too, with Danger’s curious ideas about exploring her humanity getting the first laugh from the first page (thanks to the timing that comes from a series of panels exploiting the comicbook medium’s ability to be deliberately paced) as well as becoming a running gag. Other touches are quite subtle, such as Polaris dealing with people asking about her hair or Danger “know[ing] a bar.” Not quite so obvious, but perhaps natural, would be Scarlet Witch reacting to the scene of a witch burning at the Faire, which seems a bit historically inaccurate for a writer usually concerned with authenticity but is perhaps resorting to more broad or simple plot gimmicks to tell the story he needs.

Interestingly, for a story that is arguably mostly about Polaris, she doesn’t take charge all that much. It’s not directly an indictment on her leadership skills, which is an ongoing subplot for the title, but it does fall in line with that. For example, Polaris doesn’t suggest the outing nor recommend the place for it; she doesn’t investigate the witch burning; she even allows the victim to dictate when to turn her powers off, to tell her to stop the punishment of the villain. (Although, to be fair, do we honestly think Polaris would have murdered someone in cold blood?) She does buy the Scarlet Witch a turkey leg and a beer and take some petty thieves’ gun clips, but overall she’s pretty passive to the events around her. Judging from her anger at the realization that Quicksilver was originally a plant on the team, we’re led to believe that passivity won’t be a problem for very long.

I like the fact that Danger ends up looking like Doctor Doom in her Ren Faire’s green cloak, and I like Polaris’ choice of outfit, too. The Scarlet Witch, however, can’t really pull off her look by contrast. Her regular costume in her initial appearance is quite nice, but the Ren Faire choice is some weird frumpy purple thing that doesn’t really distinguish her from her sister. Maybe that’s the point, as they are meant to bond a bit, but why go for purple?

The storytelling could have been more obvious at points. Most egregious was the way Danger tried to save the girl, which takes several panels until you realize that she transformed into a ball. The Scarlet Witch helpfully describes for us what her powers are doing in that scene, but just a couple pages back, she does *something* to the torch carried by the villain with no explanation. She could have just made the fire go out at that time, couldn’t she?     

Other places, the art is simply wrong. The women don’t really hold a turkey drumstick as much as clench fists with turkey parts coming out of either end, and when Polaris says the key line, “Girl’s day out [sic]. Sounds terrific,” her hand appears disembodied over Danger’s shoulder for some reason. And of course, there’s the final panel. X-Factor really has failed to “stick the landing” sometimes. Here, as we’ve had before, what could be a dramatic panel is instead stuck to some small barely-1/8th of a page.

The Bottom Line: While I really appreciate the appearance of the Scarlet Witch, and the resultant focus on Polaris, I feel like I miss some of the momentum that was building with the other subplots, and continue to want more balance in that respect. The characters are strong, the voices sharp and witty, but they become too isolated in their own whirling subplots, crowding out any overarching plot and even the other subplots, too. The art has only a few truly winning moments, being too scratchy and uneven overall. The cliffhanger is intriguing, and promises to bring certain things to a head that I wondered would be addressed at all.

The Grade: B

-Danny Wall

Other Tidbits:
— I remember when Marvel said they were abandoning the Comics Code Authority in favor of an in-house rating system. I don’t remember when even that was abandoned, but seeing Danger’s solicit sex from Polaris on the first page made me wonder.
— So in 40+ years of comic publishing, this is the first beer the Scarlet Witch, who was raised in central Europe, ever drank?

Grade

Conclusion