
By: Jonathan Hickman (Writer), Jim Cheung, Paco Medina, Nick Bradshaw, Dustin Weaver (Pencillers), Mark Morales, Guillermo Ortego, Juan Vlasco, Nick Bradshaw, Dustin Weaver (Inkers), Frank Martin, David Curiel (Color Artists), VC’s Cory Petit (Letterer), Jim Cheung and Justin Ponsor (Cover Artists)
The Story: Avengers: Future End, a.k.a. Civil War II
The Review: Eight months from now, the world is still spinning, although it seems all the heroes are still preoccupied with whatever threat still exists. My first impression is that we should be thankful that there is a “time jump” here, since this could have meant that, as a publishing company, Marvel could conceivably be stretching out an already-decompressed comic story for any number of more issues. My second impression is that after eight months, you’d hope that heroes would have found some more villains to battle, but instead they just keep fighting other heroes.
Last issue, Captain America was convinced that he was the hero and the Illuminati weren’t really heroic anymore, vowing to lead the Avengers and take them down. This issue, the Avengers must not be the heroes anymore, as they’ve created a police state and dress in all-black versions of their costumes. The Illuminati, by contrast, have recruited several heroes to be their underdog/ freedom fighters, including a more grown up Amadeus Cho.
This is the brightest spot for me, since I count Amadeus Cho as a favorite and of whom I had given up hope of seeing again. Here, he’s given a simple indistinct costume but a nice visual interpretation of his powers. Go, Cho!
Almost every element that is introduced, thanks to this time jump, is completely new. Nightmask’s inexplicable aging, Starbrand investigating “the Bleed,” Cannonball and Smasher’s marriage, AIM’s buyout, some new machine built by Zebra people, Thor and Hyperion brooding… Not only that, but a lot of the stuff just doesn’t flow, logically. How does SHIELD end up running so much of the world? How does the Invisible Women start working with SHIELD? How does Cannonball and Smasher give birth in under than eight months? How does Captain Marvel return to Earth? How does Sunspot buy a whole country, which was the status of AIM when we last saw it? If you tried adding this many new motifs to a complicated piece of music you’d get a discordant crash of sound. You need to end one movement before transitioning to the next. The Ex Nihili and Abyss are here, but they prove to be just as vague as ever, so the only recurring plot element is just as confusing and unfocused as before.
These chapters all have a distinct tone, too, from the mystery of Ex Nihili and the heaviness of Cho and the Illuminati rebels. There’s a balance from that with the lightness of Cannonball and Sunspot interacting, but as usual with Hickman’s writing, the tone feels more important than plot. Otherwise we might have gotten some answer, even just a tease, as to why Sunspot showed up at all, or as to what, specifically, the Ex Nihili are looking for beyond some kind of something that “lies at the center of this,” whatever “this” is.
There are a lot of artists on board for this issue, although I’m no expert and can only recognize Jim Cheung’s work at the back of the issue, as I’ve always been a fan. Cheung shows off his strengths of detailed panel illustration, clear storytelling with dynamic figures, and clear sense of layout (and of course his weakness of keeping everyone’s faces essentially the same.) His clean and sparse style makes an interesting contrast to Cannonball/Sunspot/Smasher’s scene– those faces are hyper-exaggerated and cartoony to highlight the relatively comedic tone of that section. While those choices make for appropriate matches, it kind of fragments the issue, especially when it goes from scene to scene.
So maybe this shift in art back and forth creates a rushed feeling, but I’m already chomping at the bit for the story to rush along. How can the story feel so rushed and so dragged out at the same time? I’ve given up reading in trades since reading electronically issue-by-issue is so convenient, but this, as always, just doesn’t read well issue-by-issue. I’m ready for some resolution. Still.
The Bottom Line: Shifting the setting to the near future adds a new wrinkle to the ongoing plot, but that wrinkle isn’t helping resolve anything about this old, old plot. In fact, it might just do it a disservice, since it ratchets an already-raised stakes to something that arguably has been “the new normal” for eight fictional months now, which doesn’t seem to be enough for the amount of stuff we’re expected to accept. The art is uneven thanks to the jumbling back and forth of different artists, but there are enough new design elements to help us stay visually engaged, regardless of the plot treading and re-treading.
Grade: C
-Danny Wall
Grade
Conclusion