
By: Dustin Weaver (Writer & Artist), VC’s Clayton Cowles (Letterer & Production)
The Story: People experiment on themselves? Good. People experiment on loved ones? Bad.
The Review: It’s only natural that, at this point, any new Spider-Verse characters will be compared to the previous ones, which is unfortunate, since Dr. Aaron Aikman’s version very much pales in comparison to Spider-Noir and Spider-Gwen. This comic fails in many other criteria, actually, but it’s particularly unfortunate that, like a weak, untested rock band following a slick opening cover band, he’s forced to follow after what have been so far excellent comics.
First of all, the setting of the book is a bit too vague. Is it a kind of Japan or the U.S.? A neo-futuristic world or world-next-door? The character motivations are also taken for granted. Why, exactly, would Aikman want to become a hero? Why would he want to resequence his own DNA in the first place? Why did Aikman and Kaori love each other?
This is particularly important, since time after time comic books will introduce characters that go through the motions of being a comic book while failing each and every time. The whole point of the original Spider-Man was the poignancy of his motivation and the emotional resonance of a struggling youth. There is nothing of that in Aikman’s story, meaning he fails to be a compelling story figure, let alone a true Spider-Man analogue.
Worst of all, we have to slog through four, almost five, pages of exposition before any sense of story develops. These are text-heavy info dumps, too, little more than a character’s Wikipedia entry, with the writing style to match. Nearly every narration box is a simple sentence, making me wonder if it’s purposefully trying to be a parody or simply isn’t sophisticated enough to try for a unique voice. “Redeye was the reason Aaron became the Spider-Man. He was his first foe.” I almost expected the next box to be “Redeye took 40 cakes.”
I did like the really neat touch to have some of the backstory presented via character cards, similar to Marvel’s trading cards in the 90s, but in fact it slows an already-slow reading process to a distractingly snail-like pace. Why would I want to read Redeye’s character card when I’m not even emotionally invested in any part of the world yet? This is a hallmark of fanfiction,* when there’s more attention to world-building without really trying to do actual story-building.
The writing doesn’t really improve when the story starts, resulting in some pretty stilted and overwrought dialogue. The conversation between lovers doesn’t sound natural: “Kaori, that would be wonderful, but you know we can’t do that. *I* can’t do that.. but I’m glad you’ve come. I hardly see you anymore.” And the confrontation of the villain, too: “Speak, Monster. What do you know about me?”
The comic picks up a little bit when Kaori’s “secret” is revealed. I should say, is revealed to Aikman, because any reader half-expecting a complex story could have figured it out. What’s nice about it is that the comic finally decides on a tone for its story– a sci-fi thriller. Featuring cybernetic zombies. I’m not sure if that’s “too 90s for its own good” or simply “just so five years ago.” Regardless, the most interesting part of the story so far is cut short, as a mysterious figure (Morlun, I believe) declares it to be “the end of [the] story” and that’s it. We are left to believe that this world is overrun by techno-zombies and The Spider-Man has failed. If that’s true, it’s also nice in the sense that it plays against our expectations and shows that not all our Spider-Verse characters will be recruited by the Cross-Time-Spideys.
As you can see, I was quite bothered by the story and writing, but I found the art to be pleasant enough. Where it really shines is the backgrounds. Rarely have I seen such intricate cityscapes and complex details such as the laboratory equipment and traffic. Even things like the patterns on Kaori’s dress and the carpet of Aikman’s apartment are rendered in complex detail.
I must admit, though, that I am not a fan of The Spider-Man’s costume overall. The bulky helmet, gloves, and boots look better suited for Marvel’s Super-Hero Squad. If Spider-Noir was meant to capture a specific genre, and Spider-Gwen did the same for a contemporary setting, then my only guess is that The Spider-Man is meant to invoke a purely 90s aesthetic. If so, it’s entirely successful, but too many books nowadays use this as their default style, so I’m not sure if it’s appropriate enough for nostalgia and thus comes across as uninspired. Is accidental brilliance still brilliant, or am I giving too much credit?
The Bottom Line: The comic takes too long to figure out what it wants to be, and what it wants to be isn’t very engaging after all. The writing relies too much on exposition and awkward dialogue, gives us no reason to invest in these characters, and wraps it all up in some fairly dated presentations. There’s only a few flashes of suspense, and some very lovingly detailed art, but overall it’s just too dated, too ponderous, and too uninteresting.
The Grade: C-
-Danny Wall
Other Tidbits:
— *Full disclosure: I love writing fanfiction.
— For me being pedantic about the lack of “The” in “Edge of Spider-Verse,” they make up for it here by always referring to “The Spider-Man.”
— Redeye’s first appearance (as Rick Landress) is The Spider-Man #1. His first appearance as Redeye is The Spider-Man #3. Seems like decompressed storytelling knows no dimensional bounds.
Grade
Conclusion