By: Kieron Gillen (story), Jamie McKelvie (art), Matthew Wilson (colors)

The Story: Love is letting a person break out of jail herself.

The Review: It’s not often that I can pat myself on the back for an analysis well done—I’m more likely to have my theories shot down than anything else—but I’m thinking I did a pretty good one for #2: “[P]erhaps that’s in Luci’s future. If Ananke is in control of this hopeless, almost pointless situation the Pantheon is in, maybe Luci’s inspired, rebellious nature—and her tendency toward damnation—is key to breaking the cycle.”

And what do you suppose Ananke tells Laura this issue? “Lucifer has always had trouble believing in the gods, including herself. We must make the world understand how unlike the rest of the Pantheon the Great Rebel is. Otherwise this risks being the last Recurrence…and inspiration will leave the world forever.” Boom! Nailed it. Allow me another sentence to revel in my rightness; my ego needs sustenance for the many falls ahead.

Moment of glory over, let’s talk about what Ananke’s speech means for this series. The idea that Luci can stop the Recurrence means it’s an event dependent on circumstance, not mandated by fate. This supports the idea that Ananke is maintaining the necessity that drives the Recurrence via the rules she enforces among the Pantheon. So the question we should be asking is: what are the necessary circumstances for the Recurrence?

Since I’m still pumped from my earlier validation, I’ll pitch another theory: the Recurrence depends on humanity’s desire/need for the gods. Like Amaterasu and Luci did in #1, Baal minimizes the Pantheon’s importance, saying, “We don’t get to change anything. We get to change you, and then you choose what to do with it.” They exert their influence simply by reflecting humanity in its rawest form: “When I speak, people know that in my gut, I’m bad. They feel better about being bad in their guts.” This is all textbook spiritual analysis; divinities merely serve as outsized mirrors of the people who worship them, a channel for understanding not just the world around them, but their very selves.

Are the gods a necessary channel? Luci didn’t think so, and Ananke alludes to only the vaguest consequences should the Pantheon disappear for good: “[I]nspiration will leave the world forever. Humanity would not realize what it had lost until it was gone.”

Undermining this grandiose pronouncement is the very obvious self-preservation among the gods. They accept Luci languishing the rest of her short life in prison if it’ll ensure their return, or, as Sakhmet revealingly puts it, “…then at least we’ll all get to play next time.” Play, she says. That’s pretty much what all of them have been doing, isn’t it, despite the big talk about inspiring humanity, or whatever.

But who can blame them? As they regularly remind us throughout this issue, they only have two years to enjoy the world and, lest you forget, none of them actually chose to become part of this. It’s an unfairness that only Luci has the guts to curse out loud: “Fuck the next life when I have a perfectly good one right here. Fuck anyone who thinks I should be in a cage for them. Stupid gods. Stupid humans.” If Luci rampages the way she starts to do here, it may very well be that humanity will think the gods are more trouble than they’re worth and that, perhaps, is what will end the Recurrence.

Not much action going on here, but McKelvie is one of those artists who can make even talking heads look stunning. The drama he brings to the characters is intense and powerful; even the smallest expressions seem to have a pounding significance behind them. See the Pantheon’s individual reactions to Laura accusing one of them as a murderer: Minerva’s troubled glance to her peers; Sakhmet’s contemptuous look at Laura; Baal’s indifferent and Ananke’s emotionless gaze at no one in particular; even Amaterasu’s sad little smile. But again, it may be Wilson’s colors that gives this title its power. Whether it’s the cool, sinister Tron*
lighting in the Pantheon’s sanctum or the flickering red-orange flames illuminating Luci in her ruined cell, Wilson creates the atmospheric mood that sets the scene.

Conclusion: Provoking in the most basic sense, often with thought, sometimes with the obvious.

Grade: A-

– Minhquan Nguyen

Some Musings: * Heck Wotan looks like he stole his outfit off a fallen Light Cycler.

Grade

Conclusion