By: Rick Remender (Writer), Daniel Acuña (Artist), VC’s Clayton Cowles (Letterer), Paul Renaud (Cover Artist)

SPOILER LEVEL: RED

The Story: Turn OFF the Red Skull, turn ON the ‘Slaught…

The Review: Daniel Acuña is back, and he brings with him the signature look and tone for this series, which casts the characters in a desperate and often bleak atmosphere. And when that setting is now a concentration camp and the plot features the descent of characters into evil, we’re talking some heavy, heavy atmosphere indeed. There’s an almost palpable sense of despair when reading the comic, although frankly that heightened experience is part of the reason the comic is so effective.

Among many of the artistic highlights, I direct your attention to a couple of stand-outs. The first dramatic shot of the Avengers lining up to face-off against the S-Men, shoulder to shoulder in a perspective line, reminiscent of some famous face-offs in the past; several dramatically-placed angles during the battle; and, of course, the blow-by-blow throw down between Magneto and the Red Skull, ending with an absolutely brutal finish. Acuña overall paces the panels superbly, with a sequential logic that helps guide the reader through every beat. Every oversized panel/splash page becomes that much more effective, perfectly timed and emotionally impactful, none the least of which was the Red Skull’s “final” moment, as I mentioned.

That moment is key in Magneto’s portrayal here. At first, I was a bit hesitant to accept Magneto’s presence here. He pretty much takes over the book as the star player, and it’s largely out of left field, showing up merely one issue prior. For some reason, I was thinking Remender would be leading to Magneto’s membership among the Avengers. Instead, thankfully, he’s placed here to be a foil to the Avegners’ development, as he’s a key figure to which Scarlet Witch (his daughter) and Rogue (his one-time romantic interest) can play against. These are some pretty rich backstories to play with, although I’m not quite sure they got played with to their potential here. More is done with the former, as much of the narration is done from the perspective of the Scarlet Witch, but I think there were many opportunities missed with Rogue. (Also? It doesn’t leave much, if anything, for Havok to do.)

In other words, a more fulfilling experience may come from drawing on your own knowledge of these characters and their history. The narration coming from the Scarlet Witch is a bit heavy-handed, almost too much expository, while Rogue’s dialogue is virtually out of context from her past history with Magneto. For example, when she dismisses Magneto after his murder of the Red Skull, she visually brushes him off, saying “you’re no better than him,” which would be so much more resonant when you consider that they were once lovers– Rogue sees him for a cold-blooded murderer, and realizes that she once gave her heart to that man.

That moment also serves as an interesting counterpoint to the themes of the book. The Red Skull, taken Professor X’s powers for himself, is truly the most “unified” of them all, a literal combination of human and mutant. He turns into Onslaught, which itself was a “unity” of Professor X and Magneto in its first inception. The reason for its presence here is because Magneto was acting in his own interests of revenge and (arguably justifiable) vigilantism, as self-appointed jury and executioner. The Avengers hope for public (and therefore unified) justice, but are failing because they can never be truly unified in their approach to match a more united evil.

The Bottom Line: It’s an effective book– full of drama, tension, and portent. Thanks to the moody and expressive art, which is nearly perfect in its sequential storytelling, and characters making unfortunate (but narratively resonant) decisions, this issue makes for a rich reading experience with a tantalizing momentum/cliffhanger. The full experience may rely a bit too heavily on readers’ prior knowledge of Marvel history, unfortunately, although that has been a feature of Uncanny Avengers from the beginning.   

Grade: A-

-Danny Wall

Other Tidbits:
— I always like to read the Red Skull’s voice as if it’s the character of Toht (Ronald Lacey) from Raiders of the Lost Ark. If you don’t know what I’m talking about, stop everything and go watch Raiders right now.
— Is there supposed to be a giant octopus behind the Red Skull version of Onslaught? I’m trying to figure out why his version suddenly has tentacles…

Grade

Conclusion